What the dates mean
These are the deadlines that decide whether a missing-TIN penalty can be waived. If the TIN is still missing on each date and you did not solicit by then, the "responsible manner" test in the regulation fails for that payee and the penalty stands. If you did, the payee's failure to respond is an event beyond your control and the penalty is waivable. A solicitation is a documented request for the TIN. The initial solicitation may be made in person, by mail, by telephone or electronically (a W-9 by email or a portal request). The annual solicitations must be made by mail (a letter with the $50 IRC 6723IRC 6723Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII penalty statement, a Form W-9 and a return envelope) or by a logged telephone call (Treas. Reg. 301.6724-1(e)(2))Treas. Reg. 301.6724-1Treasury regulations, Cornell LII. An email or portal reminder can go out as well, but it does not count as the annual solicitation.
Backup withholding is separate from these dates and applies from the first reportable payment while the TIN is missing. See the solicitation guide and the letter and email templates.