What it does, and what it never does
A complete, signed Form 4669 is treated as "prima facie" evidence that the payee reported the income and paid the tax (IRM 4.19.26.10.7.13.1)IRM 4.19.26.10.7.13.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Its effect is to abate the backup withholding tax for that payee for that year. Its limit is stated in the manual's opening definitions: "Provision of Form 4669 does not provide relief from penalties and interest" (IRM 4.19.26.2.3)IRM 4.19.26.2.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
The IRS makes that limit stick with a deliberate order of operations. It assesses the gross tax first, computes the failure-to-file and failure-to-pay penalties and interest on the gross, and only then abates the tax, "ensuring no reduction of penalties and interest computed on the gross tax" (IRM 4.19.26.10.7.13.3.1)IRM 4.19.26.10.7.13.3.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A payer with $100,000 of computed backup withholding and Forms 4669 for every payee still owes the 25% failure-to-file penalty, the failure-to-pay penalty and the interest, all figured on $100,000.
IRM 4.19.26.2.3IRM 4.19.26.2.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, 4.19.26.10.7.13.3.1. First Time Abate or reasonable cause, not Form 4669, is the route to the penalties.
When it is not available
"IRC 3402(d)IRC 3402Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII relief should not be offered where the Payer has failed to report on Form 945 and deposit tax that was actually withheld" (IRM 4.19.26.10.7.13)IRM 4.19.26.10.7.13Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. If you withheld from the payee and kept the money (the manual's Workstream 2), the payee's later payment of tax does not relieve you; you hold funds that belong to the Treasury. Form 4669 is for the payer who did not withhold at all.
Building a package that ties
- One Form 4669 per payee per year. A form covering two years is rejected.
- The payer may complete lines 1 through 6 (payer and payee identification, the payment type and amount). The amount on line 6 must equal the amount on the IRS's List of Payees for that payee; a rounded or partial figure is rejected.
- The payee completes Part 2: the form, schedule, line and year on which the income was reported. "Reported on my return" without those specifics is rejected.
- The payee completes the Part 3 jurat: printed name, title, signature, date and phone. The jurat text may not be altered.
- Full TINs. A truncated payee TIN is rejected, as it is everywhere in this program (IRM 4.19.26.7.1)IRM 4.19.26.7.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
- Form 4670 as the transmittal, listing every 4669 enclosed and the total.
"Unless the only missing information was the signature, the Payer will need to secure a new Form(s) 4669" (IRM 4.19.26.10.7.13.2)IRM 4.19.26.10.7.13.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A rejected form goes back to the payee, not to a correction pen.
The rejection checklist
| Defect | Result |
|---|---|
| Truncated or missing payee TIN | Rejected |
| More than one tax year on the form | Rejected |
| Line 6 amount does not equal the List of Payees amount | Rejected |
| Payee does not identify form, schedule, line and year | Rejected |
| Altered jurat | Rejected |
| Missing payee signature only | Returned for signature; the same form may be re-used |
The one-time 30-day extension in this program can be requested specifically to gather Forms 4669, at any point in the case unless the statute requires a quick assessment (IRM 4.19.26.10.5, 4.19.26.10.6.3)IRM 4.19.26.10.5Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 4.19.26.10.6.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Ask for it early; there is no second one.
What the payee is signing
Payees should know two things before they sign. The statement is under penalties of perjury and must point to a specific line of a filed return. And every accepted Form 4669 is forwarded to the IRS's Employment Tax workload selection function "for compliance review" (IRM 4.19.26.10.7.13.3.3)IRM 4.19.26.10.7.13.3.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The form is a sworn statement that the income was reported; the IRS may check.
After acceptance
If you have not yet paid, the tax is abated on assessment and the penalties and interest are billed on the gross. If you already paid the full amount, the refund of the abated tax requires a Form 945-X netting the accepted Forms 4669 (IRM 4.19.26.14.4.3)IRM 4.19.26.14.4.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Interest is never abated by the unit: "Reasonable cause is never the basis for abating interest" (IRM 4.19.26.11.5)IRM 4.19.26.11.5Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
Two procedural points from the TE/GE manuals, which describe the same process. When penalties are proposed, assessment is in two steps, and "The two-step process results in the generation of an initial billing notice for the gross amounts ... The taxpayer will subsequently receive a second notice containing the abatements allowed in the examination upon final processing of Forms 4669" (IRM 4.70.14.2.1.4.6.2)IRM 4.70.14.2.1.4.6.2Internal Revenue Manual, revised Nov. 24, 2023, irs.gov. The first bill is expected and is not a sign the Forms 4669 were lost. And the examiner gives you an extra copy of the examination report form for a reason: "The taxpayer will be instructed to file the copy of the Form 4668 along with the Forms 4669/4670 ... If the Forms 4669/4670 are received without Form 4668; return the package to the Examiner" (IRM 4.5.3.23.2)IRM 4.5.3.23.2Internal Revenue Manual, revised Sept. 29, 2015, irs.gov.
Questions people ask
Can we ask the payee for Form 4669 before the IRS contacts us?
Yes, and for a known missing-TIN population it is the cheapest insurance: obtain the TIN going forward, and a 4669 for the prior year while the payee is still reachable. The form is only useful once the IRS asserts the liability, but the signature is easier to get now.
The payee refuses to sign. What then?
The tax stands for that payee. The IRM notes the payer cannot compel it and the IRS cannot look at the payee's account to confirm reporting on the payer's behalf (IRM 4.19.26.10.7.13.1)IRM 4.19.26.10.7.13.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Recovering the amount from the payee is a commercial matter.
Does a 4669 help with the 972CG penalty for the same missing TIN?
No. Form 4669 is an employment-tax mechanism under IRC 3402(d)IRC 3402Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII. The information return penalty under IRC 6721IRC 6721Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII is a separate program with its own reasonable-cause rules (IRM 4.19.26.10.7.7)IRM 4.19.26.10.7.7Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.