- Three things it might be
- First signs
- Form 14039-B: when it is needed and when it is not
- What to send with it
- The clocks
- The letters
- What happens to the fraudulent 1099s and W-2s
- Locks, and the new-EIN question
- If it is your SSN on someone else's 1099
- When a payee says your 1099 or W-2 isn't theirs
- Questions people ask
Three things it might be
IRM 25.23.11.3(2)IRM 25.23.11.3(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, 25.23.11.2.2, 25.23.9.2(3) (Sept. 2026). Staff are told: "Never Assume Identity Theft."
The manual's first instinct is a keying error. Its probes: did the entity type change (sole proprietor to LLC, a second EIN), did the payroll company change ("the old company may still file a return or submit Form W-2"), was the business sold or closed, was a final return filed (IRM 25.23.9.4(3))IRM 25.23.9.4(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Duplicate W-2s under an old and a new EIN after an entity change "is probably not ID theft, but an internal error made by the company or payroll company" (IRM 25.23.9.4(4))IRM 25.23.9.4(4)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Rule those out before you write "identity theft" on anything, because the IRS will.
First signs
- A CP 575 or an EFTPS enrollment letter for an EIN you did not request, which for an individual means their SSN was used as the responsible party (IRM 25.23.11.6.2(1))IRM 25.23.11.6.2(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
- Balance-due notices on employment tax returns you did not file: "One or two Form 941 modules in balance due (no payments) with matching Form W-2 data may be a sign of BMF IDT" (IRM 25.23.11.3(4))IRM 25.23.11.3(4)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
- A CP2100, a Form 945 non-filer letter or a 972CG for information returns you did not file; the IRS looks at IRPTRI, "any Forms W-2 and all related income documents filed under the EIN" (IRM 25.23.9.4(4))IRM 25.23.9.4(4)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
- Letter 6042C, which means a return filed under your EIN is being held in the Return Integrity filters and the IRS wants you to confirm or deny it.
- A transcript request that suddenly fails in Business Tax Account or e-Services: transcripts are restricted "when certain identity theft indicators are present" (IRM 25.23.9.10.3)IRM 25.23.9.10.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
Form 14039-B: when it is needed and when it is not
Form 14039-B, the business identity theft affidavit, has been public since August 2020. The individual Form 14039 "is not needed for BMF ID theft" (IRM 25.23.9.2.1)IRM 25.23.9.2.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The manual is clear that the -B is often unnecessary: "A Form 14039-B is NOT required if a referral or correspondence is received and internal research shows indication of IDT. Only request additional information if it is unclear what the taxpayer is claiming" (IRM 25.23.11.7.1(2))IRM 25.23.11.7.1(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A signed letter that says what happened, with the notice attached, sent to the address on the notice, starts a case.
Two situations where you should not file it. If your return is in Return Integrity review, which is what Letter 6042C means: "The taxpayer does NOT need to file a Form 14039 or Form 14039-B. RICS will ensure all proper actions to protect the taxpayer's account are taken" (IRM 25.23.9.4.1(12))IRM 25.23.9.4.1(12)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov; answer the 6042C instead. And if the person who filed had authority to file for you, it is fraud, not identity theft, and the affidavit will be rejected (IRM 25.23.11.2.2)IRM 25.23.11.2.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
An individual who receives a CP 575 for an EIN they never requested files a 14039-B with Box 1 in Section A, not a Form 14039; phone assistors are told "DO NOT advise the caller to submit a Form 14039" (IRM 25.23.9.4.2)IRM 25.23.9.4.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Submit by mail with the notice, or through the adaptive-forms tool on IRS.gov. The signer "must have the legal authority to act for the entity" (IRM 25.23.11.6.2.2.1)IRM 25.23.11.6.2.2.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
What to send with it
| Who is claiming | Required documentation (IRM 25.23.9.7(2), (11))IRM 25.23.9.7(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov |
|---|---|
| Someone who never applied for the EIN | One clear copy of a driver's license, passport or other government ID. No proof of business operations needed. |
| Sole proprietor, active | ID plus a utility bill, mortgage or rent statement or other proof of operations: "Two documents are required." |
| Corporation, partnership, LLC, exempt organization, estate or trust | Articles of incorporation or organization, or the trust or estate document, or "a statement signed by an officer or director on corporate letterhead stationery stating that the person who signed Form 14039-B has authority to legally bind the company" (a different officer from the signer), plus a copy of the CP 575 if available. |
"Receipt of documentation from the taxpayer does not validate an identity theft claim. Proper research MUST be performed" (IRM 25.23.9.7(10))IRM 25.23.9.7(10)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The documents open the case; the IRS's own research decides it.
The clocks
| Step | Time | Cite |
|---|---|---|
| Acknowledgment of the affidavit (Letter 5316C) | Within 30 days of receipt | IRM 25.23.9.5.1(5)IRM 25.23.9.5.1(5)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov |
| Your response to a request for the form or documents | 30 days; the case is suspended 45 days; 15 more for foreign addresses | IRM 25.23.9.7.1(5)IRM 25.23.9.7.1(5)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, 25.23.11.7.4(2) |
| Resolution target | 120 days from receipt of the claim, with the scripted caveat that "inventories have increased drastically" | IRM 25.23.11.7.1(1)IRM 25.23.11.7.1(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, 25.23.11.6.3.2(2) |
| Response to Letter 6042C | 30 days from the letter date | IRM 25.23.11.6.3.2(2)IRM 25.23.11.6.3.2(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov |
| Follow-up on a return held in filters | Not before 23 weeks after the hold posted, or 9 weeks after your response | IRM 25.23.11.6.3.3(2)IRM 25.23.11.6.3.3(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov |
No reply to a document request closes the case "assuming the taxpayer is not an identity theft victim," and releases any collection hold (IRM 25.23.9.7(3))IRM 25.23.9.7(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A late reply reopens it with the original date.
The letters
| Letter | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 5316C | Acknowledgment of the 14039-B and interim letter |
| 5317C | Request for information, or the closing letter; a "no identity theft" determination must "include the specific reason(s)" |
| 6042C | Entity verification: a return under your EIN is in Return Integrity filters; reply within 30 days, by fax to 844-201-5531 or as the letter directs |
| 5263C | Entity fabrication: the IRS suspects the EIN itself is fabricated; assistors are forbidden to help with the answers |
| 6217C | Your entity has been locked |
| 916C | An amended or duplicate return on an account already deemed identity theft "will not be processed" |
| 544 | Apology for an erroneous federal tax lien caused by the theft, after release under IRC 6326(b)IRC 6326Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII |
The Return Integrity unit never sends a determination: "If RICS has made a determination of ID theft, they do not communicate with or respond back to the individual" (IRM 25.23.11.6.3.2(2))IRM 25.23.11.6.3.2(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. And "BMF identity theft indicators ... do NOT systemically generate any systemic notices to the taxpayer. All taxpayer notifications are manual" (IRM 25.23.9.5.2(2))IRM 25.23.9.5.2(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. You learn the outcome by calling.
What happens to the fraudulent 1099s and W-2s
This is the thin part. For a fraudulent tax return the manual is thorough: the return is "a nullity," backed out rather than netted, refunds are pulled back, liens released, penalties recomputed (IRM 25.23.9.9.2)IRM 25.23.9.9.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. For fraudulent income documents there is one remedy: "In situations where identity thieves filed false income documents, and a CAWR assessment has been made send a referral to the CAWR function to have the assessment reversed" (IRM 25.23.9.8.4)IRM 25.23.9.8.4Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The 2026 revision narrowed even that: "send a referral to CAWR only to have CAWR assessments reversed." CAWR is the W-2 reconciliation program. Nothing in either manual directs anyone to delete or flag the W-2 or 1099 records on the information returns file, to notify the payees named on them, or to suppress a CP2100, a Form 945 inquiry or a 972CG that those records generate.
So a payer facing a penalty notice for information returns it never filed argues it as a penalty matter, not an identity theft matter: IRS error and reasonable cause under IRC 6724IRC 6724Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII, with the identity theft case number and the 5316C as exhibits. The identity theft case will mark the account; it will not, on the text of these manuals, touch the 1099s. What you can get is copies: a legitimate business is entitled to redacted copies of the fraudulent returns and income documents, "at the time of filing all the information represented a possible liability for the business" (IRM 25.23.9.10(3))IRM 25.23.9.10(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, with TINs masked to the last four, names to the first four letters, addresses to six characters, mailed only to the address of record.
One thing the IRS does do with fraudulent 1099s is flag them for its own staff. The account-adjustment manual warns assistors: "Fraudulent IRPTR data may be submitted to the IRS by a fabricated entity or by individuals who use a valid EIN to file false Form 1099 or Form W-2 data. If either of the following warnings appear, DO NOT use this data, 'WARNING - POTENTIAL FRAUDULENT PAYER TIN' or 'WARNING - POTENTIAL FRAUDULENT SUBMISSION'" (IRM 21.6.2.3)IRM 21.6.2.3Internal Revenue Manual, revised Oct. 1, 2025, irs.gov. The warning sits on the payee-side transcript, so a payee whose refund rests on withholding from a document filed under your stolen EIN will not get it on the strength of that document. The flag does not remove the document or its CP2100 line; it tells the assistor not to rely on it.
Fake 1099s in your company's name: what the frivolous-return program does with them
Some fraudulent 1099s are not filed by identity thieves using your EIN but by individuals naming your business as their payer. The IRS's frivolous-return manual lists the pattern among its known arguments: "Form 1099-OID - Individual or business files a return reporting false amounts of income ... and claims a false amount of income tax withholding approximately equal to the amount of falsely reported income" with "Form 1099-OID (Original Issue Discount) or Form 1099-MISC" attached and some with Forms 1096 (IRM 25.25.10.21)IRM 25.25.10.21Internal Revenue Manual, revised Apr. 29, 2025, irs.gov. A related version attaches a substitute W-2 or 1099 "that shows '$0' wages" with a statement that "the taxpayer is rebutting information submitted to the IRS by the payer."
The instruction to IRS staff is to disregard such documents completely: "When working a return or claim containing a fraudulent Form 1099-OID or 1099-MISC, DO NOT use either the income or the withholding as entered on the document for purposes of determining deficiency. In the event the false Forms 1099 were processed and show on IRP, ignore it completely" (IRM 25.25.10.9.6)IRM 25.25.10.9.6Internal Revenue Manual, revised May 5, 2016, irs.gov, and "The fraudulent documents posted to IRP could be, but are not limited to Form 1099-OID (Original Issue Discount), Form 1099-MISC, Form 1099-A or Form 1099-C" (IRM 25.25.10.12.1.2)IRM 25.25.10.12.1.2Internal Revenue Manual, revised June 20, 2017, irs.gov. The submission-processing manual adds that "Filers may create a Form 2439 in the name of their employer and file it along with the Form W-2 from that employer" (IRM 3.11.3.6.1.6)IRM 3.11.3.6.1.6Internal Revenue Manual, revised Jan. 1, 2026, irs.gov, and that writing "Form 1099" or "W-2" next to a withholding claim "is not an acceptable source for withholding support" (IRM 3.11.3.14.2.29)IRM 3.11.3.14.2.29Internal Revenue Manual, revised Jan. 1, 2026, irs.gov. A business named on such a form is not treated as having filed it.
Electronic filings are screened for the same pattern at intake. Questionable files from FIRE are reviewed against frivolous-filer criteria, the example being "Excessive withholding: Pay 2 and Pay 3 are within 80% of each other," and a file that is selected leads staff to "Input TC810 with Responsibility Code 4 to hold refund" for the payees (IRM 25.25.12.18.1)IRM 25.25.12.18.1Internal Revenue Manual, revised June 13, 2023, irs.gov. A legitimate payer whose file shows withholding close to the amount paid, for example on a lump-sum distribution with heavy withholding, can see its payees' refunds held while the file is cleared.
Locks, and the new-EIN question
Once identity theft is confirmed, the IRS can lock the entity. The older locks (TC 971 AC 524 with literals such as EINFAB, BSCLSD or FNLRTN) generate a TC 020 that "will prevent the posting of returns and payments to a tax module that is not already established" (IRM 25.23.9.8.1(12))IRM 25.23.9.8.1(12)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The January 2025 ENTLOK is for a legitimate, operating business: it locks only name, address and responsible-party changes, so "requests for updates to the entity must be made in writing," phone address changes are refused, Form 8822-B is required, and every change is an unlock, change, re-lock cycle (IRM 25.23.11.6.2.1(3), 25.23.11.7.4.6)IRM 25.23.11.6.2.1(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 25.23.11.7.4.6Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A closed business can ask to be locked; inactive EINs are the stated target of thieves, "an EIN they never applied for or for a business they closed years ago" (IRM 25.23.9.2(5))IRM 25.23.9.2(5)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
A new EIN is available only "if there is federal tax administration impact," which the manual defines to include "fraudulent income documents. This would include Forms W-2, Form 1099 series" (IRM 25.23.9.9.7)IRM 25.23.9.9.7Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The route is a new Form SS-4 with the 14039-B attached, to Ogden BMF Entity, Mail Stop 6273, and the new number "is assigned and then merged with the old number." Misuse outside federal filings, credit applications and contracts, gets no new EIN; the only path is to close, rename at the state, and apply fresh.
If it is your SSN on someone else's 1099
An individual who receives an underreporter notice for wages or 1099 income "they did not work for" is not a business identity theft case at all. The affidavit, even a 14039-B, is re-typed as an individual case and sent to the IMF identity theft unit (IRM 25.23.11.7.4.9)IRM 25.23.11.7.4.9Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Answer the CP2000 by the date on it, disagreeing, and say the income is not yours; the identity theft claim runs alongside. The payee pages cover the notice side.
When a payee says your 1099 or W-2 isn't theirs
The mirror image of business identity theft is a payee telling the IRS that a document you filed under their SSN is not theirs. That claim is worked under IRM 25.23.13IRM 25.23.13Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, Income Related Identity Theft (revised Sept. 22, 2026, effective Oct. 1, 2026), which defines the problem as a TIN "used by someone else for income reporting purposes" (IRM 25.23.13.2(1))IRM 25.23.13.2(1)Internal Revenue Manual, revised June 23, 2025, irs.gov. Payers should read it for what it does not contain: no procedure for contacting the employer or payer, no letter addressed to a payer, no request for payroll records, and no instruction to the payee to obtain a W-2c or corrected 1099 from you. The claim is decided on the IRS's own screens.
IRM 25.23.13.2.1(2)IRM 25.23.13.2.1(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, (5) and 25.23.13.3(7)-(13) (Aug. 20, 2026); 25.23.13.3.1 (Jan. 31, 2023).
Research is done on command code IRPTR, the payee-side transcript: occupation against age ("a minor child working as a truck driver"), names and addresses on every document, employment history, and whether the document is "flagged as an INVALID or TIN Perfected" (IRM 25.23.13.2.1(2))IRM 25.23.13.2.1(2)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Aug. 20, 2026, irs.gov; a seventh test is redacted. Two notes make the claim automatic. "If working a current year case before June 1, accept the taxpayer's claim when the income information cannot be confirmed," and because "not all income is required to be reported to the IRS," the examiner must "Accept the taxpayer's claim when the income information cannot be confirmed other than wages (e.g. NEC, MERC, etc.)" (IRM 25.23.13.2.1(5) NoteIRM 25.23.13.2.1(5) NoteInternal Revenue Manual, irs.govs). A year "over 10 years old" that has left IRPTR is accepted the same way. A payee who disputes a 1099-NEC or 1099-K the examiner cannot see wins without evidence, and your return is never examined.
What changes is the payee's account, never your filing. The payer appears in the section once, passively, in the list of reasons not to prepare Form 9409 (IRM 25.23.13.3.1(4))IRM 25.23.13.3.1(4)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Jan. 31, 2023, irs.gov. A tax-related case (one with an assessment or refund issue) closes with TC 971 AC 501 and the literal INCOME, plus Letter 4674C where applicable (IRM 25.23.13.3(7))IRM 25.23.13.3(7)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Aug. 20, 2026, irs.gov. A non-tax-related case the taxpayer raised closes with TC 971 AC 504 and the field EMPL-M, and "Use of EMPL-M requires a manual Letter 4402C to be sent" (IRM 25.23.13.3(8))IRM 25.23.13.3(8)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A case the IRS found itself closes with TC 971 AC 506 and Letter 4674C, the "Identity Theft Post-Adjustment Victim Notification Letter" (IRM 25.23.13.3(9))IRM 25.23.13.3(9)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The case note lists "each source of income determined to be the result of IDT individually" (IRM 25.23.13.3(5))IRM 25.23.13.3(5)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, naming your company inside the IRS and nowhere else. For a 1099-NEC, MISC or K there is no further step: the section corrects only Social Security earnings records, and the information return stays on file as filed.
Wages are different. "SSA must be notified to correct the earnings record for that SSN," and the vehicle is Form 9409, IRS/SSA Wage Worksheet, required "any time you identify, during your research, any wage income on IRP docs that should not be reported under the valid taxpayer's SSN" (IRM 25.23.13.3.1(1)IRM 25.23.13.3.1(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov-(2), Jan. 31, 2023). It goes to SSA on Form 3210; if SSA has not acknowledged within 60 days the examiner resubmits, and may not "submit the same documents more than two times" (IRM 25.23.13.3.1(8)IRM 25.23.13.3.1(8)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov-(10)). One employer act stops it: the form is not prepared when "The employer indicates that the information has been corrected with SSA (Form W-2C, Statement of Corrected Income and Tax Amounts)" (IRM 25.23.13.3.1(4))IRM 25.23.13.3.1(4)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A W-2c you have already filed is the only payer action in this section that changes what the IRS does.
Two IRPTR flags close a case on their own. INVALID, with no other income at issue: "This is not considered Income Related IDT because SSA has already deemed this as invalid income, however, it is considered a loss of PII," and "Do not complete a Form 9409 for wage income identified as INVALID on IRPTR" (IRM 25.23.13.2.1(5), 25.23.13.3(11))IRM 25.23.13.2.1(5)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 25.23.13.3(11)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. TIN Perfected: closed as no identity theft, and Form 9409 is skipped because "These will be rejected by SSA" (IRM 25.23.13.3(12), 25.23.13.3.1(4))IRM 25.23.13.3(12)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 25.23.13.3.1(4)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
"This is not considered Income Related IDT because this is caused by an IRS error" is the manual's verdict when the disputed document shows "Valid Perfected SSN" on its Payee Entity Data line (IRM 25.23.13.2.1(5))IRM 25.23.13.2.1(5)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Aug. 20, 2026, irs.gov. Read from the payer's side: the IRS's own TIN perfection can attach your return to an SSN you never filed, the manual calls the result an IRS error, and the payer is not notified.
Business and platform cases have their own routing (IRM 25.23.13.2.1.1)IRM 25.23.13.2.1.1Internal Revenue Manual, revised Dec. 1, 2023, irs.gov. No affiliation with the EIN, or a Form 14039-B submitted, sends the case to the business identity theft function under IRM 25.23.2.4.3(8)IRM 25.23.2.4.3(8)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, the path this guide describes. If the EIN is the taxpayer's own but "They did not receive some or all of the income reported as MERCH, NEC, Other Income, etc." and research supports it, the case closes as income-related identity theft; anything else goes on Form 4442 to identity theft headquarters, which owes an answer "within 7 business days." The platform that issued the 1099-K is not told.
What should a payer do when a payee asks? No IRS letter is coming; the request will come from the payee. Check the W-9 and payment records. If they match, say so in writing and keep the exchange; the IRS decides on its own research and your return stays on file either way. If the return was wrong, correct it: a W-2c is the one filing the manual recognizes (IRM 25.23.13.3.1(4))IRM 25.23.13.3.1(4)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, and a corrected 1099 is the only thing that changes the payee's record for non-wage income. The manual never mentions CP2100, Notice 972CG or backup withholding, and does not say what happens on the payer side when wages leave a payee's SSA record while your W-2 reporting stays intact. Keep the payee's correspondence with the return; if that SSN later appears on a mismatch listing, the file is your reasonable cause.
Questions people ask
We got a CP2100 listing payees we have never paid. Is that identity theft?
Possibly, or another filer keyed your EIN as the payer. Ask the help desk which TCC filed the returns on the notice; a payer is entitled to the business name behind the TCC on its own notice. A transmitter you do not recognize is the fork between mixed entity and identity theft.
Will the IRS remove the fraudulent 1099s from our account?
The manuals contain no procedure to do so. They reverse W-2 reconciliation assessments and correct tax returns. Treat any penalty on the fraudulent information returns as a penalty case with the identity theft file as evidence.
Our former payroll provider is still filing W-2s under our EIN.
That is the manual's own example of a mixed entity or, if the provider was still authorized, fraud. Revoke the authorization in writing, file Form 8822-B if the address changed, and report the filings as erroneous rather than as identity theft.
How long does an entity lock last?
The manuals set no expiry for ENTLOK or for the "Identity Theft" sort-name literal. Plan on the written-change procedure indefinitely.