What the calculator applies
- Schedule. Form 945 uses the Form 941 deposit rules with an annual lookback: the tax on the Form 945 filed for "the second calendar year preceding the current calendar year." $50,000 or less makes you a monthly depositor, due the 15th of the following month; more makes you semiweekly, due the following Wednesday for Wednesday-to-Friday liabilities and the following Friday for Saturday-to-Tuesday, always with at least three business days after the period (IRM 20.1.4.8.2IRM 20.1.4.8.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov to 8.5). A new payer with no lookback is monthly.
- The $100,000 rule. Accumulating $100,000 in a deposit period makes that amount due the next business day, and a monthly depositor "immediately becomes a semi-weekly depositor for the remainder of the current calendar year and the following calendar year" (IRM 20.1.4.8.6)IRM 20.1.4.8.6Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
- Business days. Only Washington, D.C. legal holidays move a due date; state holidays do not, "as [deposits] are made by EFTPS" (IRM 20.1.4.7.3)IRM 20.1.4.7.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
- The tiers. 2% one to five days late, 5% six to fifteen, 10% more than fifteen, and 10% for "required deposits not paid by EFT"; a further 5% attaches to tax still unpaid more than ten days after the first notice, which this tool flags but does not add (IRM 20.1.4.7.1)IRM 20.1.4.7.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
- Application. By default "deposits are applied to the most recently ended deposit period or periods" (Rev. Proc. 2001-58; IRM 20.1.4.7.4(11))IRM 20.1.4.7.4(11)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Within 90 days of a penalty notice you may designate the order instead, including oldest-first, and "Do not assess the additional penalty unless the taxpayer agrees" if the designation raises it (IRM 20.1.4.26.3)IRM 20.1.4.26.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Toggle the setting to compare.
- Safe harbor. No penalty on a shortfall of no more than the greater of $100 or 2% of the amount due, if it is made up by the return due date (monthly) or by the earlier of the first Wednesday or Friday on or after the 15th of the following month and the return due date (semiweekly) (IRM 20.1.4.8.7)IRM 20.1.4.8.7Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
- Under $2,500. If total tax for the year is under $2,500 no deposits are required and the tax may be paid with the return. At $2,500 or more, "any amount paid with the return is subject to the 10 percent avoidance penalty" (IRM 20.1.4.6(6))IRM 20.1.4.6(6)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov; the test is annual, with no prior-year lookback as on Form 941.
How the IRS's own program (FTDPN) computes it
"Command Code FTDPN is used by IRS employees as a calculator for manually computing FTD penalty" (IRM 2.3.28.2(1))IRM 2.3.28.2(1)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Jan. 1, 2023, irs.gov. It covers Form 945 (MFT 16) alongside Forms 941, 943, 940, 944, CT-1 and 1042 (IRM 2.3.28.5)IRM 2.3.28.5Internal Revenue Manual, revised Jan. 1, 2007, irs.gov, and it "does not compare its results against the Master File penalty computation" (Exhibit 2.3.28-13 Note); a sibling command, PIFTD, does that and shows "MATCH" or "MISMATCH." This calculator follows FTDPN's rules where the manual states them.
Allocation: Most Recent is the default, FIFO is gated. The program applies each deposit to the most recent liability unless told otherwise. A first-in, first-out display is allowed only in a narrow case: for annual forms including MFT 16, "whenever two semiweekly liability due dates (Wednesday and Friday) occur in the same week at least once per quarter (MFT 01) or four times per year (MFT 11, 16, 09, 12, 14)." Otherwise, "if the FIFO computation is more than $250.00, the FIFO computation is blocked and a warning message will be displayed: *Warning: FIFO is not applicable. Enter 'M' for Most Recent Computation*" (IRM 2.3.28.9(2))IRM 2.3.28.9(2)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Jan. 1, 2007, irs.gov.
"Do not send FIFO computation unless it agrees with taxpayer's designation" is the warning the program displays whenever it shows a first-in, first-out alternative (IRM 2.3.28.9(2))IRM 2.3.28.9(2)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Jan. 1, 2007, irs.gov. A payer who wants deposits applied in a particular order has to designate them; the IRS will not assume FIFO.
Designation. "To designate a particular TC650, user can now input 'L##' by overlaying the existing 650. The 'L' indicates that the credit (650) is being designated to a certain Incurred Liability Number (##) skipping the FIFO method" (Exhibit 2.3.28-10 Note 6). When a deposit is undesignated and a liability is still open the screen warns "NON-DESIGNATED DEPOSIT, UNSATISFIED TAX LIABILITY REMAINING - PLEASE DESIGNATE" (IRM 2.3.28.8.1)IRM 2.3.28.8.1Internal Revenue Manual, revised Jan. 1, 2009, irs.gov, and explanation code 16 marks a designated credit. The penalty notice itself tells the payer there are "90 days from the date of the penalty notice to contact the IRS and designate the deposit period or periods ... to which the deposits of tax are to be applied" (Exhibit 2.3.28-20, paragraph 230). The deposit designation request template is written for that window.
Safe harbor and shortfall. Explanation code 05 reads: "The undeposited taxes are less than or equal to 2% of the tax liability or $100.00 of the tax liability, whichever is greater. The remaining undeposited taxes are due the first Wednesday or Friday on or after the 15th of the following month." Code 06 is the monthly-depositor version, "due at RDD"; codes 07 and 08 describe a shortfall "carried forward and due with the return" or to the first Wednesday or Friday on or after the 15th (Exhibit 2.3.28-14). The screen shows the figure as "SAFE HAVEN AMOUNT DUE" with an "SF Due Date" (Exhibits 2.3.28-13, -25). Code 14 records that the de minimis amount rose from $1,000 to $2,500 for Forms 941, 943 and 945 from the 2001 first quarter.
Averaging when there is no valid Form 945-A. With no valid liability schedule, a semiweekly Form 945 is averaged so that "the total tax amount is divided by 48 with the result displayed on the first four Wednesdays of each month"; a monthly Form 945 is divided by 12 onto the monthly due dates (IRM 2.3.28.3.1)IRM 2.3.28.3.1Internal Revenue Manual, revised Jan. 1, 2007, irs.gov. With monthly totals but no schedule, each month is divided by four onto its first four Wednesdays (IRM 2.3.28.3(5)IRM 2.3.28.3(5)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov-(6)). The screen literal is "AN AVERAGE IS REFLECTED IF NO PERIODIC LIABILITY AMOUNT WAS POSTED" (Exhibit 2.3.28-5 Note 2). A payer whose backup withholding is concentrated in one part of the year is penalized for "late" deposits against liabilities it never had until a Form 945-A is supplied; the averaged penalty page covers the fix.
How the output reads. The 2013 and later summary screen is one line per event: liability number, date and amount; "PR End Date/Due Date/SF Due Date"; the deposit type ("Deposit(EFT)/Deposit(neft)/Deposit/No Deposit/Payment/Excess Pymt") with its date, split number and amount; "SUBJECT TO PENALTY," "DAYS LATE," "RATE nn% nn = 2, 5, 10, or 15" and "DEPOSIT PENALTY" (Exhibits 2.3.28-25, -26). The breakdown page carries "TAX LIABILITY INCURRED DATE," "ACCUMULATED TAX LIABILITY," "APPLIED DEPOSIT," "UNDEPOSITED TAXES," "AMOUNT SUBJECT TO FTD PENALTY," "15% PENALTY DATE" and "NEW UNDEPOSITED BALANCE," with a totals page at 2, 5, 10 and 15 percent (Exhibit 2.3.28-13). Two limits of the manual: it describes no "P" summary print (the only "p" in the exhibits is a pre-1993 pre-deposit marker), and it gives no tie-break rule between Most Recent and a designation beyond the warning quoted above. Explanation code 20 is worth knowing: a credit transferred in from another module "can't be identified as EFTPS," so the 10 percent avoidance tier is not assessed on it unless an employee inputs a manual TC 180 (Exhibit 2.3.28-14).
What it does not do
It does not compute failure-to-file or failure-to-pay penalties on the return itself (see the Form 945 page: no FTF if deposits covered 100% by January 31, no 60-day minimum), interest, or the averaged penalty the IRS assesses when the Form 945-A is missing or does not add to line 3 (IRM 20.1.4.18)IRM 20.1.4.18Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. It assumes each deposit was made through EFTPS unless marked otherwise, and that no CP 161 has issued. Figures are estimates; the FTDPN computation on a CP 210 or CP 568 controls.