See also: SSNVS, the SSA name and SSN check for employees.
- Two programs, two letters
- The four fields that are matched
- Where Form 945 comes in: 1099-R and W-2G withholding
- The letter sequence
- Clocks, thresholds and the two-to-three-year lag
- PRN 549 and PRN 550
- No First Time Abate, and the supervisory approval point
- What to send
- W-2C or 941-X: the floor rule
- Traps the manual describes
- Questions people ask
Two programs, two letters
The Combined Annual Wage Reporting program has "two basic components," the manual says. IRS-CAWR is the tax side: it compares "the employer's data provided to the IRS on Forms 941, 943, 944, 945 or Schedule H to the data provided to SSA on Forms W-2/W-2-C and/or to the IRS on Forms 1099-R and W-2-G" and issues Letter 99-C, the "Letter of Employment Tax Problem" (IRM 4.19.4.1.1(2), 4.19.4.11(2), 4.19.4.3.48(4))IRM 4.19.4.1.1(2)Internal Revenue Manual, revised June 11, 2025, irs.govIRM 4.19.4.11(2)Internal Revenue Manual, revised June 11, 2025, irs.govIRM 4.19.4.3.48(4)Internal Revenue Manual, revised June 11, 2025, irs.gov. SSA-CAWR is the penalty side: SSA has already written twice about W-2s it could not reconcile, and the IRS issues Letter 98-C proposing information return penalties (IRM 4.19.22.2(1))IRM 4.19.22.2(1)Internal Revenue Manual, revised July 2, 2025, irs.gov. "When referring to all Form 941, Form 943, Form 944, Form 945, this IRM will read 94X" (IRM 4.19.22.1.1(1))IRM 4.19.22.1.1(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, so Form 945 filers are in scope even with no employees. The program compares employer-level totals, never individual W-2s by name or SSN (IRM 4.19.4.11.1(1))IRM 4.19.4.11.1(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
The four fields that are matched
"IRS matches four fields, Social Security wages, Social Security tips, Medicare wages and tips, and Federal Income Tax (FIT) withheld," and a case is created when the reconciliation "results in an apparent underpayment of taxes or over withholding of FIT" (IRM 4.19.4.1.8(2))IRM 4.19.4.1.8(2)Internal Revenue Manual, revised June 11, 2025, irs.gov. SSA's own pre-match uses only the first three: "SSA only matches three fields during their reconciliation" (IRM 4.19.4.1.8(9))IRM 4.19.4.1.8(9)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A withholding mismatch is therefore always an IRS-CAWR matter, never an SSA one.
The manual's list of causes: wage statements "under one EIN and Form 94X under a different EIN," math errors, third-party sick pay, the wrong period, a missing return, and missing W-2s or W-3s (IRM 4.19.4.11(8))IRM 4.19.4.11(8)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Mar. 28, 2018, irs.gov. It also concedes that "IRS processing errors in recording Forms 94X-X are often the source of out of balance conditions" (IRM 4.19.4.3.4(5))IRM 4.19.4.3.4(5)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. On a transcript the CAWR module is MFT 88, and "A Blocking Series of 55 on the last available quarter with a TC 150 present indicates CAWR made an adjustment" (IRM 4.19.4.11.1(3) Note)IRM 4.19.4.11.1(3) NoteInternal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
You can check the arithmetic on a Letter 99-C. The system manual for the CAWR case system (IRM 4.19.8IRM 4.19.8Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, last revised Sept. 25, 2020) lists "the tax rates CAP uses to calculate the tax displayed in the tax column," and the amounts on that screen are what the weekly letter run uses (IRM 4.19.8.7.2(2), 4.19.8.7.4.1(1))IRM 4.19.8.7.2(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 4.19.8.7.4.1(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov:
| Field that is out of balance | Rate applied to the gap | On a $50,000 gap |
|---|---|---|
| Social Security wages | 12.4% | $6,200 |
| Social Security tips | 12.4% | $6,200 |
| Medicare wages | 2.9% | $1,450 |
| Federal income tax withheld | 100% | $50,000 |
Those are the combined employer and employee rates, and the whole withholding gap is treated as tax. The list has no rate for Additional Medicare Tax. The comparison that counts is the 94X total against the processed W-2 total: the W-2 column "is compared to the Form 94X column to calculate wage/tax differences," while the W-3 column "is used as a tool to help identify possible processing errors within the Forms W-2" (IRM 4.19.8.7.2(1))IRM 4.19.8.7.2(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. If your W-3 total agrees with your 941s and the processed W-2 total does not, say so in the reply; that pattern points at processing, not at your payroll.
SSA also marks each W-3 record with a problem indicator that the examiner sees. The 2020 manual's table includes "Duplicate Forms Deleted" (D), "Apparently Missing Forms" (L), "Social Security Wages Over Maximum" (M), "Illegible Forms" (P) and "Form W-3 Record but No Form W-2 Record" (Q) (IRM 4.19.8.7.6(2))IRM 4.19.8.7.6(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. When an assistor says SSA shows missing forms, ask which indicator is on the record. It tells you what kind of problem SSA recorded, and so what to send.
Where Form 945 comes in: 1099-R and W-2G withholding
Form 945 is a 94X for CAWR, but only some of what it reports has anything to match against. The information returns feeding the withholding side are Forms W-2, 1099-R (document type 98) and W-2G (document type 32). "The only information returns filed with IRS that may include FIT are the Form 1099-G, Form W2-G, and Form 1099-R... Form 1099-G FIT amounts are not included in the reconciliation balancing phase of CAWR" (IRM 4.19.4.2.3(1) Note)IRM 4.19.4.2.3(1) NoteInternal Revenue Manual, revised Apr. 14, 2020, irs.gov. Backup withholding on Forms 1099-NEC, MISC, INT and DIV is not named anywhere in either section. A Form 945 built from it has nothing on the other side to tie to, which is how a Form 945 "over withholding of FIT" case is born.
The screener is told how to close that case without writing. "When the only (or only remaining) discrepancy is for FIT and the exact amount is reported as Backup Withholding (BUWH) on the Form 945 and no other BUWH is required to be reported," the examiner checks PMFOL, the file built from your Form 1096 transmittals, for the amount; a match closes the case in screening. The same applies when the backup withholding exceeds the gap and PMFOL shows the rest on another return. But "When the BUWH is less than the discrepant amount, or there are other fields that remain discrepant, issue correspondence" (IRM 4.19.4.2.3(1)IRM 4.19.4.2.3(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov to (4)). The Form 945 checker runs that screen on your numbers.
"The amounts reported on Forms 1099-R and W2-G are not generally subject to Backup Withholding, so the amount shown is Federal Income Tax Withheld" (IRM 4.19.4.3.32(1))IRM 4.19.4.3.32(1)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Feb. 1, 2008, irs.gov. If a payer tells the IRS its 1099-R withholding was reported as backup withholding, the examiner sends a Letter 2057-C "informing the taxpayer that Forms 1099-R are not subject to Backup Withholding and that we have adjusted their account accordingly" (IRM 4.19.4.3.32(2))IRM 4.19.4.3.32(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The account is fixed by reclassification; the notice cycle is the cost.
Line 2 of Form 945 is where this goes wrong: pension, annuity and gambling withholding belongs on line 1, only IRC 3406IRC 3406Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII backup withholding on line 2. The other pattern is the plan administrator: "Discrepancies are usually caused when the taxpayer fails to file Forms 945/1099-R or has a third party administrator." The administrator's EIN resolves a no-945 case with a cross-reference; but if a Form 945 was filed and "Form 1099-R (Doc Code 98) money amounts are more than Form 945" with no explanation, the IRS assesses the difference on the Form 945 module and may add a failure-to-deposit penalty (IRM 4.19.4.3.33(1))IRM 4.19.4.3.33(1)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Apr. 22, 2022, irs.gov.
The letter sequence
IRM 4.19.4.1.8(11)IRM 4.19.4.1.8(11)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, 4.19.4.3.1(1) and (5), 4.19.4.2.14(1), 4.19.4.6.1(8) and (11) (June 11, 2025 and Apr. 10, 2024); IRM 4.19.22.2.3.1(2)IRM 4.19.22.2.3.1(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov (July 2, 2025). The IRS-CAWR opener is Letter 99-C; the manual states no reply window for the employer, but the IRS holds a no-reply case for an 81-day suspense period before it assesses (IRM 1.4.22.4.5(1))IRM 1.4.22.4.5(1)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Apr. 30, 2024, irs.gov.
Letter 98-C is mass generated "at a determined volume per week ... up to and including cycle 33" (IRM 4.19.4.2.14(1)IRM 4.19.4.2.14(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov to (4), Apr. 14, 2020); Letter 99-C opens an IRS-CAWR case (IRM 4.19.4.3.48(4))IRM 4.19.4.3.48(4)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Letter 5825-C is the interim letter, issued at 25 days open, then every 55 days (IRM 4.19.22.2.3.1(2))IRM 4.19.22.2.3.1(2)Internal Revenue Manual, revised July 2, 2025, irs.gov. Letter 2057-C is the closing and explanation letter, and also the one that asks for more reasonable-cause detail (IRM 4.19.4.7(4), 4.19.4.3.1.4(7))IRM 4.19.4.7(4)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 4.19.4.3.1.4(7)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The penalty arrives as a CP 215 on the civil penalty module, MFT 13 (IRM 4.19.4.3.1.1(1))IRM 4.19.4.3.1.1(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov; a denial of reasonable cause comes on Letter 854-C with "the specific reason" (IRM 4.19.4.6.1(11))IRM 4.19.4.6.1(11)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Apr. 10, 2024, irs.gov. The SSA letters that precede all this, SSA-L-94-SM and SSA-L-96-SM, are not IRS correspondence (IRM 4.19.4.11.1(2))IRM 4.19.4.11.1(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
The first letter comes out of a mass run, not off an examiner's desk. The coordinator guide says it in one line: "Currently only mass generated cases are being worked" (IRM 1.4.22.2(4))IRM 1.4.22.2(4)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Apr. 30, 2024, irs.gov. The 2020 system manual describes the run: "Once a week CAP will process all cases in status codes "16" and "90" and create the letters automatically. The amounts reported in the money amount screen and address information contained in the entity screen will be used to create the letter information" (IRM 4.19.8.7.4.1(1))IRM 4.19.8.7.4.1(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Two things follow for an employer. The letter goes to the entity address the IRS has on file, so an old address means a letter you never see; file Form 8822-B when you move. And the first person likely to look at the numbers is the examiner who opens your reply, so the reply has to explain the gap without help.
Large corporations get one extra step. Before a letter is issued on a large corporation or large dollar case, the money screen is faxed to the Large Corporation Technical Unit for the employer's state, and "The LCTU has 10 business days to supply any additional information." If that does not resolve the gap, or nothing comes back, the examiner is directed "to issue the appropriate correspondence" (IRM 1.4.22.10.6(2) and (3), Apr. 30, 2024)IRM 1.4.22.10.6(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
Clocks, thresholds and the two-to-three-year lag
"The taxpayer is given 45 days to answer the Letter 98-C. If the taxpayer does not respond to the letter by the end of the suspense period (11 cycles from letter date) the case becomes a No Reply. Status code 91 automatically posts ... The Intentional Disregard Penalty automatically assesses when the BMF posts status code 91" (IRM 4.19.4.3.1(5))IRM 4.19.4.3.1(5)Internal Revenue Manual, revised June 11, 2025, irs.gov. Clerical staff treat a letter "close to 81 days prior to the current date" as about to go no-reply (IRM 4.19.22.2.1.1(1))IRM 4.19.22.2.1.1(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, and the coordinator guide confirms the number: "Once the 81 day suspense period has expired the CAWR program will automatically run through the nightly no reply process" (IRM 1.4.22.4.6(1))IRM 1.4.22.4.6(1)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Apr. 30, 2024, irs.gov. The machinery acts at 81 days while the letter says 45, and the penalty takes about a month more to show on the account: "It takes 30 days from the time the case updates to status 91 for the auto-assessment of the Civil Penalty to post" (IRM 1.4.22.11(6))IRM 1.4.22.11(6)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Treat 45 as the deadline; the manual allows one suspension of "30 days from the date of the employer's correspondence" (IRM 4.19.4.3.29(1))IRM 4.19.4.3.29(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. For Letter 99-C the manual states no reply window for the employer, but it does give the hold: "Once the 81 day suspense period has expired, additional tax due is assessed on the last available quarter of the tax year being worked" (IRM 1.4.22.4.5(1))IRM 1.4.22.4.5(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
Size decides the path at status 91: "Penalties of less than $25,000.00 automatically assess on IDRS. Penalties of between $25,000.00 and $999,999.99 are held in a re-sequencing file until after PCD ... Penalties of 1 million dollars or more do not automatically assess" (IRM 4.19.4.3.1(5))IRM 4.19.4.3.1(5)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A tolerance below which nothing is assessed exists but is redacted (IRM 4.19.4.2.14(4) Note)IRM 4.19.4.2.14(4) NoteInternal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. On the tax side, no-reply cases are auto-assessed on the last quarter of the year; an assessment of $100,000 or more requires "subsequent contact" first and a supervisor's signature (IRM 4.19.4.4(1)IRM 4.19.4.4(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov to (3) and (12)).
What is already on your account decides whether a machine or a person makes that tax assessment. "The majority of the IRS-CAWR No reply cases will now be auto assessed on the CATRS system by the technical coordinator. However, cases containing any of the following TC codes will need to be manually reviewed and assessed by a tax examiner: 160, 161, 180, 181, 340, 370, 400, 420, 424, 480, 520, 530, 766, 780, 788, 910, 912, 914, 916, or 918" (IRM 1.4.22.4.5(2))IRM 1.4.22.4.5(2)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Apr. 30, 2024, irs.gov. The guide does not explain the list. In the IRS code book (Document 6209) those numbers cover, among other things, late filing and deposit penalties and restricted interest (160 to 181, 340), an examination (420, 424), an offer in compromise (480, 780, 788), a bankruptcy or litigation hold (520) and currently not collectible status (530). The same list takes a Letter 98-C case with tax due out of the automatic run (IRM 1.4.22.4.6(3))IRM 1.4.22.4.6(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The assessment run is weekly (IRM 1.4.22.4.5(3))IRM 1.4.22.4.5(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A manual review is not a second notice. The guide mentions no new letter at that point, only a tax examiner who reviews and assesses in place of the batch job.
The lag is built in. Tax year 2023 IRS-CAWR cases were released April 7, 2025, with Letters 99-C mailed by December 15, 2025; tax year 2022 SSA-CAWR letters were issued by August 9, 2025 (IRM 4.19.4.10(4) and (5))IRM 4.19.4.10(4)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The coordinator guide gives the standing calendar. IRS-CAWR starts "Within one week of the HUB release date. Generally the first of April," and SSA-CAWR on the same schedule. Letter 98-C volume "must be generated before Cycle/ Week 33 each year. Letter 99-C can be issued thru mid December" (IRM 1.4.22.4.2(2))IRM 1.4.22.4.2(2)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Apr. 30, 2024, irs.gov. SSA-CAWR must be closed by "The last day of November (95 percent) and two weeks later (100 percent)," and IRS-CAWR by "The last day of the following March (100 percent)" (IRM 1.4.22.5.1(1))IRM 1.4.22.5.1(1)Internal Revenue Manual, revised July 16, 2025, irs.gov. For the current cycle that meant November 28 and December 13, 2025 for tax year 2022 SSA-CAWR cases, and March 27, 2026 for tax year 2023 IRS-CAWR cases (IRM 1.4.22.5.1(2) and (3))IRM 1.4.22.5.1(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A Letter 99-C dated late in the year leaves little calendar: the 81-day hold can end within weeks of the closing date, so do not count on a second exchange of letters. The manual says it plainly: "the Forms W-2 were due two to three years prior to the IRS issuing the Letter 98-C and that SSA has previously contacted the taxpayer twice" (IRM 4.19.4.3.1.4(5))IRM 4.19.4.3.1.4(5)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The assessment statute "is 3 years from the due date of the return" (IRM 4.19.22.4(3))IRM 4.19.22.4(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Late replies are "Recons," worked with balance-due notices suspended (IRM 4.19.4.6(1)IRM 4.19.4.6(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov to (4)). A closed case can still be pulled up for one: the 2020 system manual describes an archive query "used to access late reply case that no longer exist in CAP," which "When filled to capacity ... will contain seven years of archived case information" (IRM 4.19.8.5(2) and Note)IRM 4.19.8.5(2)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Sept. 25, 2020, irs.gov. If the assessment has already gone to a revenue officer, the officer can ask the CAWR unit to fix it: "the revenue officer will submit a Form 3870, "Request for Adjustment" to request an adjustment or abatement of the CAWR assessment and/or civil penalty," and "These cases will be worked within 45 days of receipt into the department on a first-in-first out (FIFO) basis while workload permits" (IRM 1.4.22.10.5(1) and (2), July 16, 2025)IRM 1.4.22.10.5(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Give the officer the same package you would have sent in reply to the letter.
Each CAWR case carries a two-digit status or closing code on the CAWR module (MFT 88), and a call to the IRS will often be answered in these terms. The ones a payer is most likely to hear, from Document 6209 (2023), Section 11:
| Code | IRS definition |
|---|---|
| 69 | 98C issued |
| 16 | Auto generated 99C letter |
| 44 | Reply to CAWR Correspondence (No Gen Code S) |
| 24 | IRS Undeliverable |
| 25 | Open Case Referral to Exam |
| 29 | Open Case Referral to Collection |
| 91 | SSA IND = 2, Penalty Assessment from CAP to BMF. BMF posts Penalty |
| 34 | Closed CAWR (no SSA IND = 2) TC 290 zero with TP Reply Received |
| 35 | Closed CAWR (no SSA IND = 2) TC 290 with money amount with TP Reply Received |
| 37 | Closed CAWR (no SSA IND = 2) No Reply Received |
| 48 | Full Agreed IRS CAWR |
| 49 | Missing Returns Secured IRS CAWR |
A 34 is the result to want: the case closed after your reply with no change in tax. Status 91 is the no-reply path the manual describes above, where the penalty posts automatically.
The 2025 CAWR manager guide words some of these differently. It lists 37 as an open status, "OPEN_NO_RESPONSE (Open No Reply - IRS CAWR)", with 30, "CLS_NO_RESPONSE (Closed No Reply IRS CAWR)", as the closing code, and it gives the mass-mailed Letter 98-C its own status, 90, "OPEN_LTR_98_AUTO (Open Auto Letter 98-C issued - SSA CAWR)", keeping 69 for a 98-C an examiner sends by hand (IRM 1.4.22IRM 1.4.22Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, Exhibits 1.4.22-2 and 1.4.22-3, July 16, 2025). If the IRS tells you 37, ask whether the case is still open.
PRN 549 and PRN 550
PRN 549, intentional disregard, IRC 6721(e)IRC 6721Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII. "Imposed on employers who do not comply with our requests to file correct Forms W-2." The statute offers the greater of a per-form amount or 10 percent of the aggregate amount, but the manual picks one: "use only the 10 percent of the aggregate amount method due to a problem with the data appearing in the number of employees field on the Form 94X returns and CATRS." The examiner adds Social Security wages and tips, compares that and Medicare wages to the W-2 fields, and is told to "Assess the 10 percent Penalty on the larger discrepancy." "There is no maximum to the Intentional Disregard penalty" (IRM 4.19.4.3.1.1(1) and (2))IRM 4.19.4.3.1.1(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The 10 percent runs on the wage gap, not the tax: a $200,000 gap is a $20,000 penalty on top of any tax. Federal agencies, defunct or bankrupt entities, unamended IRC 6020(b)IRC 6020Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII quarters and cases where "The only wage field out of balance is Total Compensation" are excluded (IRM 4.19.4.3.1.1(3))IRM 4.19.4.3.1.1(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
PRN 550, late-filed W-2s, IRC 6721(a)IRC 6721Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII. Assessed "in the reply phase, when original Forms W-2 filed in response to SSA-CAWR correspondence are received. These forms are always subject to the maximum penalty of $290.00 ($280 for tax years 2020-2021, $270 for tax years 2018-2019, $100 for tax years 2010 through 2014 and $50.00 for SSA CAWR tax years 2009 and prior) for each Form W-2" (IRM 4.19.4.3.1.2(1))IRM 4.19.4.3.1.2(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Note the word maximum: CAWR applies the top per-form rate however late the W-2 is, unlike the tiers in Pub 1586. The floor: "Assess Late Filing Penalty if you have two or more Form W-2" (IRM 4.19.4.3.1.3(3))IRM 4.19.4.3.1.3(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Forms count as late originals when you do not say they were filed before, or say so and "BMFOLU and SSA (ORS or ERQY) research does not support the claim" (IRM 4.19.4.3.1.2(2))IRM 4.19.4.3.1.2(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A partial reply draws both, PRN 550 on the forms received and PRN 549 on the remaining gap (IRM 4.19.4.3.1.3(3))IRM 4.19.4.3.1.3(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The penalty estimator works both.
No First Time Abate, and the supervisory approval point
"Chief Counsel has determined the First Time Abate Penalty relief option does NOT apply to the Intentional Disregard Penalty (PRN 549) under IRC Section 6721(e) or the Late Filing Penalty (PRN 550) under section 6721(a). These penalties can only be abated based on Reasonable Cause criteria ... DO NOT abate PRN 549 or 550 penalties based on First Time Abate" (IRM 4.19.4.3.1(1) Note)IRM 4.19.4.3.1(1) NoteInternal Revenue Manual, revised June 11, 2025, irs.gov.
The standard is Treas. Reg. 301.6724-1Treas. Reg. 301.6724-1Treasury regulations, Cornell LII: a responsible manner before and after, plus mitigating factors or events beyond your control. Responsible manner means "actions they took when the error was first identified AND subsequent actions taken to prevent future occurrence," and the statement must cover the whole period: "Any reasonable cause documentation must address the issue preventing the filing of the Forms W-2 from the period they were due up to and including the time of their response to IRS" (IRM 4.19.4.3.1.4(2)IRM 4.19.4.3.1.4(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov to (5)). The examiner's checklist is two questions. Did you react timely upon discovery? If not addressed, a 2057-C asks "what took place at the time the error was discovered." Did you act to prevent recurrence? If not addressed, the examiner pulls the following year's filing: timely means met; the same error again means assessed (IRM 4.19.4.3.1.4(6)IRM 4.19.4.3.1.4(6)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov to (8)). A good compliance history "should be considered whether or not the taxpayer specifically requests waiver on this basis"; reliance on a payroll provider is "not a basis for reasonable cause ... that responsibility cannot be delegated" (IRM 4.19.4.3.1.4(9) and (10))IRM 4.19.4.3.1.4(9)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The CAWR reasonable-cause statement is built on that checklist.
One procedural point: supervisory approval of the initial 98-C "is not required" because it is calculated electronically, but "Once the taxpayer responds to the Letter 98-C, the tax examiner's evaluation of the response, regardless of whether or not the taxpayer specifically addresses the penalty, means that the 'automatically calculated through electronic means' exception no longer applies and written supervisory approval is needed" (IRM 4.19.4.7.1(2)IRM 4.19.4.7.1(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov to (7), Apr. 14, 2020). A payer contesting a PRN 549 or 550 assessed after it replied can ask whether written IRC 6751(b)IRC 6751Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII approval is in the file.
What to send
| Your position | Send | Manual |
|---|---|---|
| The W-2s exist; here they are | Copies, or a listing: "a computer listing providing the employee name, SSN, wages, tips, federal income tax withheld" is accepted "as if it was the actual Form W-2." Not tape or disc; magnetic media is rejected and PRN 549 follows. | IRM 4.19.4.3.1.3(2)IRM 4.19.4.3.1.3(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov and (3); 4.19.4.3.7(1) |
| We filed them on time | The W-3, W-2 copies other than Copy A, and a timely dated return receipt. A W-3 alone is not accepted. | IRM 4.19.4.6.1(1)IRM 4.19.4.6.1(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov |
| The 941s were overstated | Form 941-X per quarter with an "Authorized Original Signature"; a documented fax is accepted. | IRM 4.19.4.3.4(6)IRM 4.19.4.3.4(6)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov; 4.19.4.3.22 |
| A third party paid or filed | Its name and EIN and a "Copy of the cancelled check (front and back) payable to the US Treasury." "Do not just accept the taxpayer's statement." | IRM 4.19.4.3(11)IRM 4.19.4.3(11)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov |
| 1099-R withholding was under the plan administrator | The administrator's EIN; the IRS verifies and cross-references it. | IRM 4.19.4.3.33(1)IRM 4.19.4.3.33(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov |
| A 94X was never filed | The return; processed as an original "even if the return was marked copy." | IRM 4.19.4.3.6(1)IRM 4.19.4.3.6(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov |
| A representative will handle it | Form 2848 listing specific periods; the IRS will not disclose to a POA "completed using general references such as ('All years', 'All periods', or 'All taxes')." | IRM 4.19.4.3.38(2)IRM 4.19.4.3.38(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov and (3) |
"A copy of Form W-3 with a timely signature date should not be accepted alone as evidence because a fictitious document can be easily prepared. However, if a taxpayer provides a copy of Form W-3 and copies of Form W-2 other than copy 'A' along with a timely dated return receipt, all penalties should be abated" (IRM 4.19.4.6.1(1))IRM 4.19.4.6.1(1)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Apr. 10, 2024, irs.gov.
The explanations that close a case are not a mystery. When an examiner corrects the W-2 side of a case, the system makes the examiner pick a reason from a fixed list, and the 2020 system manual prints it (IRM 4.19.8.7.8(3))IRM 4.19.8.7.8(3)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Sept. 25, 2020, irs.gov. Read it as a checklist: if one of these is your story, say it in those terms and enclose the proof.
| Reason on the IRS list | When it is your explanation |
|---|---|
| "Adjustments per corrected Forms W-2" | You filed Forms W-2c that change the totals. Send copies of the W-2c and W-3c. |
| "To post original Forms W-2 sent by employer" | W-2s you filed are missing from the processed total. Send copies or a listing. |
| "Transfer-Forms W-2 posted to wrong EIN" | The W-2s sit under a different EIN than the 94X. Give both EINs and say which is right. |
| "Transfer to correct tax period" | The W-2s were counted in the wrong year. |
| "DUP W-2" | The same W-2s were counted twice. |
| "SSA balancing error" | Your W-3 and W-2s agree with your 94X returns, and the processed total does not. |
| "Wages Over Max" | A W-2 shows Social Security wages above the annual wage base. |
| "FICA tips included in FICA wages" | Tips were reported inside the Social Security wages figure. |
| "Family Employment" and "Minister Wages" | Listed without a definition. Both name wages an employer may treat as outside Social Security and Medicare tax, so explain the exemption you relied on. |
The list ends with "Other," so it is not exhaustive. The correction is made on an internal Form 6209, and "the form is electronically forwarded to IDRS to update the Form W-2 amounts reported on CC BMFOLU" (IRM 4.19.8.7.8(1) Note)IRM 4.19.8.7.8(1) NoteInternal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, which is the W-2 total the next examiner will see.
Never send forms alone. "When Form W-2 are received with no additional correspondence attached, the Loose Forms W-2 must be immediately input on the CATRS System to show Loose Forms W-2 are on file for that EIN" (IRM 1.4.22.10.7(1))IRM 1.4.22.10.7(1)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Apr. 24, 2023, irs.gov. Loose forms are given a serial number, filed, and "held for use in the appropriate tax year's program when it is worked" (IRM 1.4.22.10.7(5) Note)IRM 1.4.22.10.7(5) NoteInternal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The examiner later sees only a banner with that serial number (IRM 1.4.22.10.7(6))IRM 1.4.22.10.7(6)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Nothing in the file says what the forms were meant to prove. The same goes for third-party sick pay: "Form 8922 Third Party Sick Pay Recap reconciles 3rd party sick pay with Forms 94X for tax years 2014 and subsequent. This form will be mailed directly to the CAWR units based on state mapping and will be input and treated like loose Form W-2" (IRM 1.4.22.10.7(2))IRM 1.4.22.10.7(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. If sick pay paid by an insurer or other third party explains your gap, name the Form 8922 and who filed it in your reply. Put a cover letter on everything, with the EIN, the tax year and the letter number.
The Letter 98-C / 99-C reply template organizes these enclosures; replies go by mail or fax (IRM 4.19.22.2(3))IRM 4.19.22.2(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
W-2C or 941-X: the floor rule
"Do not decrease the 94X account below the amounts reported on the Forms W-3/W-2 and W-3C/W-2-C" (IRM 4.19.4.3.4(6))IRM 4.19.4.3.4(6)Internal Revenue Manual, revised June 11, 2025, irs.gov, and for assistors, "DO NOT ALLOW THE TAXPAYER TO ADJUST THE LIABILITY BELOW THE FORMS W-2/W-2-C TOTALS" (IRM 4.19.4.11.3(4))IRM 4.19.4.11.3(4)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Apr. 22, 2022, irs.gov. The W-2 totals on file are the floor under your employment tax; a 941-X alone cannot take you under them.
The only W-2C changes CAWR forwards are Social Security or Medicare wage changes and SSN-only corrections; a W-2C that changes only the pension indicator does nothing for the case (IRM 4.19.4.2.12(2), 4.19.4.3.40)IRM 4.19.4.2.12(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 4.19.4.3.40Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
A 941-X requesting an increase is treated as an agreed, interest-free assessment (IRM 4.19.4.3.4(6))IRM 4.19.4.3.4(6)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. On withholding, Chief Counsel ruled for the payer: "IRS cannot hold employers liable for the federal income tax withholding shown on the original Forms W-2 if the amounts on the Forms W-2C are correct, even if employees received credit based on erroneous Form W-2" (IRM 4.19.4.11.4(2) Note)IRM 4.19.4.11.4(2) NoteInternal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
Traps the manual describes
"When the taxpayer submits a payment for the proposed discrepancy, and no correspondence is attached ... Assess the intentional disregard penalty ... Assess tax and any related penalties" (IRM 4.19.4.3(9))IRM 4.19.4.3(9)Internal Revenue Manual, revised June 11, 2025, irs.gov. Paying the letter without explaining it is read as agreement to the tax and as intentional disregard on the W-2 side.
- Undeliverable letters are assessed, with a 15 percent penalty. After a 14-day address search the case is assessed as undeliverable, and undeliverable IRS-CAWR cases get "the full 15 percent FTD penalty" automatically (IRM 4.19.4.5.1IRM 4.19.4.5.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, 4.19.4.7.4(4) Note). The IRS will not take your address from the returned envelope: addresses "can be updated on IDRS only if the taxpayer submits Form 8822, Form 8822-B, or a written request" (IRM 4.19.4.5.1)IRM 4.19.4.5.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
- You cannot call the CAWR unit. "Never provide the voice number of the CAWR unit to the taxpayer or transfer the call to the CAWR unit ... You may only provide the taxpayer with the Fax number" (IRM 4.19.4.11.1(4)IRM 4.19.4.11.1(4)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov to (7)). See calling the IRS about a notice.
- W-2s after the CP 215 have ten days. W-2s postmarked "within 10 days of the CP 215 notice date" convert PRN 549 on those forms to PRN 550; later, and not found on SSA's systems, "Intentional Disregard Penalty (PRN 549) will remain on the account as originally assessed" (IRM 4.19.4.6.1(8))IRM 4.19.4.6.1(8)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
- The payroll service is your problem. If your information does not resolve the case the IRS assesses and tells you "they may need to contact their payroll service" (IRM 4.19.4.3.25(1))IRM 4.19.4.3.25(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
Questions people ask
We only file Form 945 for backup withholding on 1099-NECs. Can CAWR reach us?
Form 945 is a 94X in the program, but its withholding is compared only to Forms W-2, 1099-R and W-2G. The screener closes a backup-withholding-only case when PMFOL shows the same total (IRM 4.19.4.2.3)IRM 4.19.4.2.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, so if Form 1096 box 4 and Form 945 line 2 agree, no letter should issue.
Can we get First Time Abate on the CP 215?
Not for PRN 549 or 550: "DO NOT abate PRN 549 or 550 penalties based on First Time Abate" (IRM 4.19.4.3.1(1) Note)IRM 4.19.4.3.1(1) NoteInternal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Reasonable cause is the only path; the relief order guide compares this with 972CG penalties.
We filed one W-2 late in our reply. Is there a penalty?
"Assess Late Filing Penalty if you have two or more Form W-2" (IRM 4.19.4.3.1.3(3))IRM 4.19.4.3.1.3(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. One late W-2 is not penalized under PRN 550, though any remaining wage gap still draws PRN 549.
Our reply was denied. How do we appeal?
The Letter 854-C carries appeal rights. A follow-up disagreement needs a signed request or a Form 2848 for the specific periods; "A Form 8821 or Form 2848, Level H, is not considered an authorized POA" (IRM 4.19.4.6.2(1)IRM 4.19.4.6.2(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov to (6)). The coordinator guide shows where that request goes. "Requests for relief from civil penalty assessments received after the initial request for relief has been denied through the issuance of Letter 854-C are generally considered an appeal of the previous penalty relief denial" (IRM 1.4.22.10.3(1))IRM 1.4.22.10.3(1)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Apr. 6, 2020, irs.gov. So a second letter generally goes to Appeals, not back to the examiner who denied you. The file must hold your signed request and "A copy of the original Letter 854-C," so enclose one. Completed files "will be forwarded to the Ogden Appeals Campus Office," and the unit is told to "Issue Letter 86-C to the taxpayer and use 90 days as the contact time frame" (IRM 1.4.22.10.3(3) and (5))IRM 1.4.22.10.3(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Expect Letter 86-C first, then contact from Appeals, with 90 days as the stated time frame.