TIN ComplianceA resource from TIN Comply
Foreign payees and screening · From the IRS manual

How the IRS examines a payer's foreign vendors: W-8s, presumption rules and the Form 1042 clock

A Form 1042 examination of a company that is not a bank starts with the accounts payable file and the vendor master, not with the return. The examiner's manual sets out the three-step sweep that turns a vendor list into a list of suspected foreign payees, the checklist applied to every W-8 the company produces, the presumption rules for the vendors with no W-8, the late-W-8 cure with its 30-day and one-year lines, and the deposit clock on Form 1042 that most payers have never seen.

Updated November 15, 2026Reading time 10 minutesSources IRM 4.10.21 (May 12, 2026); IRM 3.21.110 and 3.22.111 (Sept. 5, 2025); IRM 20.1.4.11 (Apr. 17, 2026); Treas. Reg. 1.1441-1, 1.1441-7, 1.1471-3

How the case starts

The Foreign Payments Practice in LB&I downloads every 1042-S the payer filed and scores it: the risk metric is "(Gross Income Amount times 30%) minus Amount Withheld," with a three-year comparison of reported payments and a note that "improper income code use could be an indication for a potential examination lead" (IRM 4.10.21.8, 4.10.21.9.8)IRM 4.10.21.8Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 4.10.21.9.8Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Industries called out: professional services partnerships, high tech, entertainment and publishing, pharmaceuticals, real estate, daily fantasy sports and online advertising (IRM 4.10.21.10.2)IRM 4.10.21.10.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Related-party returns are mined too: Form 5471 Schedule M and Form 5472 Parts IV and VI list royalties, guarantee fees, insurance premiums and "other amounts paid" to foreign affiliates, and if no 1042-S matches them, "an explanation should be provided by the taxpayer" (IRM 4.10.21.10.5)IRM 4.10.21.10.5Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.

The opening questions are about records: is the W-8 system paper or electronic, does each recipient have a folder, does the company have an electronic-W-8 memorandum with the IRS and follow it (IRM 4.10.21.8)IRM 4.10.21.8Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Then the written procedures: system flowcharts, W-8 validation, undocumented-account handling, deposits, reimbursement and escrow, and how the presumption rules are applied (IRM 4.10.21.9.1.1)IRM 4.10.21.9.1.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A company with no written procedure for undocumented vendors has already answered a question.

The vendor-file sweep

For a non-financial payer, IRM 4.10.21.10.3IRM 4.10.21.10.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov is a three-step procedure applied to the accounts payable and vendor files.

  1. Flag possible foreign payees by any of: an EIN beginning with 98; an ITIN (a TIN beginning with 9); a country that is not the U.S. or is blank; a ZIP code not in U.S. format; a state that is not a U.S. state or is blank; a foreign city; the payer's own foreign-vendor coding; "any other factors." The list is presented to the company, which may remove payees it "can establish" are not foreign.
  2. Identify the FDAP payments among what was paid to that list: interest, royalties, rents, dividends, services performed in the United States by a nonresident, pensions. The examiner tests the expense categorization first, because "a contract for computer hardware might include a service component."
  3. Source the income. "The regulations ... require that the income payments be presumed U.S. source when the source is not known to the payer ... The taxpayer has the burden of proof to overcome the presumption." Services are sourced where performed, royalties where the property is used, rents where the property is, interest and dividends by the payer's residence.

The closing test is arithmetic: "If less than 30 percent was withheld and reported on the filed forms, the examiner should request and examine the Forms W-8 and Forms 8233." Paid FDAP with no 1042 or 1042-S filed: "substitute or delinquent return procedures should be followed" (IRM 4.10.21.10.6)IRM 4.10.21.10.6Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The W-8 validity calculator runs the sweep's first step on a vendor row and the checklist's expiration test on the form.

The W-8 checklist examiners apply

Three steps for every certificate (IRM 4.10.21.9.6)IRM 4.10.21.9.6Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov: a line-by-line review of the form itself, a comparison against the account file for contradictions, and an expiration check. The specific points: the name matches the records; the chapter 3 status "is reasonable"; a U.S. TIN is present when required; a treaty actually exists with the country claimed; every element of a treaty claim is present, including the specific limitation-on-benefits provision for an entity; chapter 4 status and GIIN for a withholdable payment to an entity, with the GIIN verified against the published FFI list; the form is signed and dated (or date-stamped on receipt); it is the correct revision; and a foreign TIN, or a "reasonable explanation" for its absence, and date of birth for accounts at U.S. offices.

"Avoid focusing on insignificant failures. The absence of a foreign or U.S. TIN when either is required is not an insignificant failure" (IRM 4.10.21.9.6(1))IRM 4.10.21.9.6(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.

The reasonable explanation for a missing foreign TIN "includes a statement that the entity is not legally required to obtain a TIN in its jurisdiction," written on the form, in the margin, or attached (IRM 4.10.21.6.3)IRM 4.10.21.6.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A treaty claim where "there is no U.S. income tax treaty in force with the recipient's country of residence during the year of payment" is automatic reason to know (IRM 4.10.21.7.2)IRM 4.10.21.7.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. On limitation on benefits, the examiner "generally need not require ... an attachment ... describing the beneficial owner's analysis"; the checked box suffices absent actual knowledge (IRM 4.10.21.7.1.4.1)IRM 4.10.21.7.1.4.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.

U.S. indicia that kill reliance

A facially valid W-8 is unreliable if the payer's own records contradict it: a U.S. mailing address, a U.S. driver's license used as identification, a U.S. birthplace on the passport, a hold-mail instruction, a U.S. telephone number, or a classification as a U.S. person in the payer's systems (IRM 4.10.21.9.6(1)(b))IRM 4.10.21.9.6(1)(b)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A payer that relies on an onboarding agent "is generally considered to know, or have reason to know, facts within the knowledge of its agent" (IRM 4.10.21.9.3.1)IRM 4.10.21.9.3.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The chapter 4 regulation says the same, and adds that a payer relying on the status its agent assigned, without reviewing the documents itself, "will be liable for any underwithholding that results from a failure of the agent to assign the correct status based upon the available information" (Regulations 1.1471-3(e)(4)(ii)(A), (c)(9)(i))Treas. Reg. 1.1471-3Treasury regulations, Cornell LII. The standard is whether the information "would cause a reasonable person to question the claims made." When it does, the payer "must generally either withhold at the maximum tax rate of 30% or withhold at the backup withholding rate (currently 24%), as determined based on the presumption rules" (IRM 4.10.21.9.3)IRM 4.10.21.9.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.

No W-8: the presumption rules

Actual knowledge runs only one way, toward more withholding: a payment to a U.S. person known to be acting for a foreign person is treated as made to the foreign person (IRM 4.10.21.9.3.2)IRM 4.10.21.9.3.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A nonqualified intermediary that does not allocate its withholding statement has the undocumented portion "treated as allocated to unknown recipient and subject to 30% withholding tax" (IRM 4.10.21.9.10.9.2)IRM 4.10.21.9.10.9.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.

Late and defective W-8s: the cure

When the W-8 arrivesWhat makes it acceptable for the earlier payment (IRM 4.10.21.9.7.3)IRM 4.10.21.9.7.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov
Within 30 days of the paymentNothing more: it "will not be considered unreliable solely because it does not contain an affidavit."
More than 30 days, up to one yearA signed, dated affidavit under penalties of perjury that the information was accurate at the time of payment.
More than one year after the paymentThe affidavit plus documentary evidence: a government ID without a U.S. address or a foreign certificate of incorporation; for a treaty claim, photo identification issued within three years, otherwise a bank statement or utility bill. Under the regulations the evidence depends on the claim. For chapter 3 it supports the claim of foreign status, or any treaty claim made on the form (Regulations 1.1441-1(b)(7)(ii)(A))Treas. Reg. 1.1441-1Treasury regulations, Cornell LII. For a withholdable payment to an entity it must be documentary evidence "that supports the chapter 4 status claimed," for example an organizational document, a financial statement or a third-party credit report for an entity that is not a participating or registered deemed-compliant FFI (Regulations 1.1471-3(c)(7)(ii), (c)(5)(ii)(A))Treas. Reg. 1.1471-3Treasury regulations, Cornell LII. If something other than a W-8 arrives more than a year after the payment, a W-8 and affidavit are needed as well.
A late W-8ECIThe affidavit must state that the income was or will be included on a U.S. return.

Address defects are cured for an individual with a foreign government ID without a U.S. address plus "a reasonable written explanation from the account holder supporting foreign status," and for an entity with formation documents; treaty claims need residency documentation in the treaty country (IRM 4.10.21.9.7.2)IRM 4.10.21.9.7.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Once the IRS tells a payer a claim is incorrect, the payer "will have actual knowledge ... beginning on the date that is 30 calendar days after the date the notification is received" (IRM 4.10.21.7.1.4.3)IRM 4.10.21.7.1.4.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The late W-8 affidavit template has the wording.

Errors the file can cure, and errors it cannot. A payer "may treat a withholding certificate as valid, notwithstanding that the withholding certificate contains an inconsequential error, if the withholding agent has sufficient documentation on file to supplement the information missing from the withholding certificate due to the error," and that documentation "must be conclusive" (Regulations 1.1471-3(c)(7)(i)Treas. Reg. 1.1471-3Treasury regulations, Cornell LII; chapter 3 adopts the same definition in 1.1441-1(b)(7)(iv)). The regulation's example is a country of residence abbreviated in an ambiguous way, cured by government issued identification from a country that reasonably matches the abbreviation. Four defects are named as not inconsequential, so documents already on file do not cure them: no entity type selected, "even if the withholding agent has an organization document for the entity," where the entity was eligible to make a check-the-box election; a "failure to check a box to make a required certification on the withholding certificate"; a missing country of residence or treaty country; and information that "contradicts other information contained on the withholding certificate or in the customer master file."

How long a W-8 lasts

The general rule is the signature date through December 31 of the third following year: "a Form W-8BEN signed September 2019 will expire 12/31/2022." A W-8BEN or BEN-E supported by documentary evidence with no U.S. address, phone or standing instructions is valid indefinitely, but "the portion ... that includes the treaty claim is subject to the general 3-year validity rule." A W-8ECI is always three years. A W-8EXP is indefinite for governments and central banks, and for a tax-exempt organization only "provided that the withholding agent reports on Form 1042-S at least one payment annually to the entity." A W-8IMY is indefinite but the certificates under it are not. Documentary evidence lasts three years or its own expiration; non-renewable documents such as a certificate of incorporation, indefinitely (Exhibit 4.10.21-3). A change in circumstances invalidates a form when the payer "knows or has reason to know" of it; the payee has 30 days to report one, and payers "are required to notify any person providing documentation of the person's obligation to notify the withholding agent of a change" (Exhibit 4.10.21-1). Form 8233 is annual. A Form W-9 collected for chapter 3 purposes "must be retained for three years from the date the account is opened."

What the regulations add. The manual's summary of indefinite validity is broader than the regulations in two places. For an individual, the W-8BEN and the documentary evidence must be provided within 30 days of each other (Regulations 1.1441-1(e)(4)(ii)(B)(1))Treas. Reg. 1.1441-1Treasury regulations, Cornell LII. For an entity paid a withholdable payment, holding the form with documentary evidence of foreign status keeps the chapter 4 status valid only for the entity types in Regulations 1.1471-3(c)(6)(ii)(C)(2)Treas. Reg. 1.1471-3Treasury regulations, Cornell LII, other than a section 501(c) entity: a retirement fund or an entity wholly owned by one, an excepted nonfinancial group entity, a nonprofit organization, a nonreporting IGA FFI, a territory financial institution, an NFFE whose stock is regularly traded, an NFFE affiliate, an active NFFE that the payer's AML due diligence shows is in a business other than that of a financial institution, and a sponsored FFI (paragraph (c)(6)(ii)(B)(3)). A passive NFFE is not on that list, so its chapter 4 status runs out under the three-year rule. Separately, the form of a participating or registered deemed-compliant FFI whose GIIN the payer has verified, and a form from a foreign government, a government of a U.S. territory, a foreign central bank or an international organization, stay valid for chapter 4 until circumstances change (paragraphs (c)(6)(ii)(B)(1) and (5)). The W-8 validity calculator page has the full table.

On changes, chapter 4 counts a change of address or telephone number "only if it changes to an address or telephone number in the United States," lets the payer keep the old chapter 4 status for up to 90 days after the form became invalid, and requires the payer to "institute procedures to ensure that any change to the customer master files that constitutes a change in circumstances" is identified (Regulations 1.1471-3(c)(6)(ii)(A) and (E))Treas. Reg. 1.1471-3Treasury regulations, Cornell LII. A W-8 has no fixed retention period: it is kept "for as long as it may be relevant to the determination of the withholding agent's tax liability" (Regulations 1.1441-1(e)(4)(iii) and 1.1471-3(c)(6)(iii)(A))Treas. Reg. 1.1441-1Treasury regulations, Cornell LIITreas. Reg. 1.1471-3Treasury regulations, Cornell LII.

One exam, two returns: 1042 and 945

"A major determination for a withholding agent is in properly documenting or otherwise classifying a recipient as either a U.S. or a foreign person," and reclassifying vendors from foreign to U.S. "produces collateral adjustments to Forms 1099 and 945" (IRM 4.10.21.4)IRM 4.10.21.4Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The examiner protects both statutes, Form 872 for the 1042 and Form SS-10 for the 945 (IRM 4.10.21.8)IRM 4.10.21.8Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A payee that is an exempt recipient for 1099 purposes is "not necessarily exempt from the NRA withholding requirements," and a 1042-S is required even where nothing is withheld: "a payment may be reportable even if it is not withholdable." Under IRC 1461IRC 1461Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII the payer is liable for the tax it did not withhold, and under 1463 for interest and penalties even where the payee paid. The reasonable-cause factors weighed against a payer: "ignorance of the law is generally not accepted"; where withholding is "part of the ordinary course of business ... it may be more difficult"; a repeat adjustment on the same issue is worse; compliance with a prior remediation plan helps (IRM 4.10.21.12.3)IRM 4.10.21.12.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.

The Form 1042 deposit clock

Undeposited chapter 3 and 4 taxDeposit due (IRM 3.21.110.17, 20.1.4.11.1)IRM 3.21.110.17Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 20.1.4.11.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov
$2,000 or more at the end of a quarter-monthly period (the 7th, 15th, 22nd and last day of the month)Within three business days after the period ends
$200 to under $2,000 at the end of a monthBy the 15th of the following month
Under $200 at the end of the yearWith the Form 1042 by March 15
$200 or more at the end of December, paid with the return"May be subject to the 10 percent avoidance penalty" (IRM 20.1.4.6(9))IRM 20.1.4.6(9)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov

Deposits go through EFTPS. The record of liability on the return (lines 1 to 60) must show quarter-monthly liability dates, and "the examiner should ensure that the withholding agent did not instead complete this section ... based on deposit dates, as this error may prevent identification of late deposits" (IRM 4.10.21.9.1.2)IRM 4.10.21.9.1.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A blank schedule is averaged by 24 for penalty purposes; a negative entry is zeroed with a notice. Form 7004 extends the filing date to September 15 but "does not provide additional time to pay" (IRM 20.1.4.11)IRM 20.1.4.11Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. And a 1042 deposit penalty "will not systemically recompute" when 1042-S credits change; it must be requested (IRM 20.1.4.22(6))IRM 20.1.4.22(6)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.

What Ogden does and does not check

At processing, the 1042-S is barely validated. A recipient TIN of all zeros or all nines: "continue processing as is." A missing income code, exemption code or unique form identifier: research, and if nothing is found, continue. "Research is not required when a valid TIN is not present on an electronic Form 1042-S" (IRM 3.22.111.11.3.27)IRM 3.22.111.11.3.27Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The instruction repeated across the correction manual is "DO NOT change information submitted by the Withholding Agent." There is no CP2100 for 1042-S recipients, no processing-level TIN match, no GIIN check against the FFI list. What processing does enforce is the transmittal: a 1042-T whose chapter, amended, pro-rata or partnership indicators do not match its 1042-S forms is "not correctable" and the batch is renumbered and re-input, and a non-correctable record "will not post" to the information returns file, so the recipient's credit never becomes matchable (IRM 3.22.111.10.4.8, 3.22.111.9)IRM 3.22.111.10.4.8Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 3.22.111.9Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Everything the processing side lets through, the examination side tests. That is why the missing foreign TIN that Ogden waves past is "not an insignificant failure" in the field.

Questions people ask

Our vendor has a 98-prefix EIN but a U.S. address and a W-9. Foreign or not?

The 98 prefix puts it on the sweep's list, and the manual notes that before 2001 only foreign corporations had 98 or 33 prefixes. A W-9 from a U.S. entity settles it as U.S. for the payer, but the examiner will look at what else is in the file; a foreign incorporation document beside the W-9 is reason to know.

The W-8BEN-E has no foreign TIN. Is the whole form bad?

For a financial account at a U.S. office, a missing foreign TIN without a reasonable explanation is a material failure. For an ordinary vendor payment the TIN requirement depends on the claim: a treaty claim on a W-8BEN-E generally requires a U.S. TIN or a foreign TIN in lieu of it, with exceptions for marketable securities (IRM 4.10.21.6.3)IRM 4.10.21.6.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Get the explanation written on the form either way.

We found unfiled 1042-S forms for prior years. Is there a disclosure route?

Yes, at IRM 4.10.21.14IRM 4.10.21.14Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov: one complete submission to the Foreign Payments Practice with six years of returns, a reconciliation, a four-question statement, a declaration signed by the payer (not the representative), and the tax paid; the 1042-S must show the tax as paid by the withholding agent in box 11. Not available to anyone already contacted, anyone who used it in the past five years, or QIs. No closing agreement is issued and penalty relief "is not guaranteed."

Does the 30% presumption apply to services we paid a foreign contractor for work done abroad?

Services are sourced where performed. Work performed entirely outside the United States is foreign-source income, not FDAP subject to withholding, but the burden of showing where the work was done is the payer's, and the contract, invoices and travel records are what the examiner asks for.