- What these documents are
- PMTA 2023-03: the CP2100 does not erase prior liability
- The two conditions, kept separate
- CCA 200941012: intentional disregard applied
- The four factors, as Counsel weighed them
- Thirteen older memos on 1099s, TINs and withholding
- Twenty more memos from the full archive
- Recent written determinations, 2023 to 2026
- How to use them
- Questions people ask
What these documents are
Program Manager Technical Advice and Chief Counsel Advice are written legal advice from the Office of Chief Counsel to IRS operating divisions, released under IRC 6110IRC 6110Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII with identifying details removed. Each carries the warning that it "may not be used or cited as precedent." Their value to a payer is different: they show the position the IRS will take, in the words its own lawyers used, and they are often adopted into the manual. PMTA 2023-03 is cited by name in the employment tax examiner's manual (IRM 4.23.8.14.1)IRM 4.23.8.14.1Internal Revenue Manual, revised Apr. 17, 2024, irs.gov as the reason a payor "must backup withhold during the period during which the TIN has not been furnished in the manner required, regardless of whether the payor receives and complies with a CP2100." The intentional disregard memo is older, but the regulation it applies is unchanged apart from renumbering.
PMTA 2023-03: the CP2100 does not erase prior liability
The memo, dated June 29, 2023, from Procedure and Administration to Employment Tax Policy, poses two scenarios. In the first, "The payor made a reportable payment to the payee, but the payee did not furnish its Taxpayer Identification Number (TIN) to the payor. The payor did not backup withhold. The IRS sent the payor a CP2100/2100A notice stating that the payor needs to secure the payee's TIN by having the payee send a Form W-9 to the payor. The payor followed the compliance instructions." In the second, the payee had furnished a TIN on a W-9, the IRS notified the payor it was incorrect, and the payor "followed the compliance instructions in the CP2100/2100A notice by timely sending a blank Form W-9 to the payee and informing the payee that backup withholding will begin if the payee does not send back an executed Form W-9." The question: "does the payor's compliance with the instructions stated in the notice imply that the payor does not have backup withholding liability under section 3406(a)(1)(A) with respect to a reportable payment made before compliance?"
"Under section 3406(a)(1)(A), the payor must backup withhold during the period during which the TIN has not been furnished in the manner required, regardless of whether the payor receives and complies with a CP2100 or CP2100A notice" (PMTA 2023-03, June 29, 2023, Conclusion).
The reasoning turns on the statute's structure. "The disjunctive 'or' in the rule indicates that the condition under section 3406(a)(1)(A) for imposing backup withholding is independent of the condition under section 3406(a)(1)(B)." For (A), "backup withholding is required during the period during which the TIN has not been furnished in the manner required"; for (B), "beginning after the close of the 30th day after the day on which the payor received the notification ... and ... ending before the payee furnishes another TIN in the manner required." A CP2100 "provides the notice described in section 3406(a)(1)(B)," and complying with it "may lead to the condition stated in section 3406(e)(2)(B) (the payee furnishing another TIN in the manner required) being met ... in which case backup withholding under section 3406(a)(1)(B) can cease." But the notice "is not relevant to the imposition backup withholding obligations under section 3406(a)(1)(A)."
"compliance with the CP2100 or CP2100A has no bearing on the backup withholding liability under section 3406(a)(1)(B) that existed for the period before compliance," and "complying with all the instructions stated in a CP2100 or CP2100A notice does not affect backup withholding liability that was preexisting under section 3406(a)(1)(A) before the notice was sent" (PMTA 2023-03).
Applied to the scenarios: in the first, "at the time of the reportable payment, the payee had not furnished any TIN to the payor. The condition for imposing backup withholding with respect to that payee under section 3406(a)(1)(A) is met. Thus, the payor was obligated to backup withhold. If the payee thereafter furnishes a Form W-9 to the payor, then within 30 days of receipt of the Form W-9, the payor should stop backup withholding." In the second, the incorrect-TIN condition "is separate from the backup withholding obligation under section 3406(a)(1)(A). The CP2100 or CP2100A notice does not affect the preexisting backup withholding liability under section 3406(a)(1)(A)." The memo quotes the regulation's general rule: "A payor must continue to withhold under section 3406 until no condition for imposing backup withholding exists with respect to the payee" (Treas. Reg. 31.3406(e)-1(a))Treas. Reg. 31.3406(e)-1Treasury regulations, Cornell LII.
The two conditions, kept separate
PMTA 2023-03, Scenarios 1 and 2; Treas. Reg. 31.3406(e)-1(a)Treas. Reg. 31.3406(e)-1Treasury regulations, Cornell LII, (b); 31.3406(d)-5(e), (g)(3).
The practical consequence is the one the examination guide describes: an examiner computes withholding on a missing-TIN payee from the first payment, not from the 30th business day after a CP2100, and a payer's defence that it "followed the notice" answers only the incorrect-TIN side. The TIGTA figures on the inspector general page are built on the same reading. What does help on the missing-TIN side is Forms 4669 and 4670 for payees who reported the income, and the regulation's 30-day stop once a certified TIN arrives.
CCA 200941012: intentional disregard applied
The memo advised whether the IRS "may determine an intentional disregard penalty under Section 6721(e) against Company A for failing to timely file information returns for Year 5." Company A was one of the largest Form 1099 filers in the country, executing trades for financial institutions, with filings that grew from N1 to N3 forms over five years. The facts Counsel recited: for Years 1 and 2 the returns were filed late and under both Company A's and an acquired company's names; the IRS sent 972CG notices, Company A explained the lateness by computer problems "at both Company A and the Service's FIRE unit" and promised that "the proper resource and system commitments" had been made, and "the Service waived the penalties for both years." Years 3 and 4 were late again. For Year 5, FIRE staff emailed in May and August and the IRS wrote in July asking when the returns would be transmitted; "Company A ignored these contacts and filed its information returns in October of Year 6." After being told intentional disregard was under consideration, Company A filed Year 6 on time despite a three-fold volume increase.
Counsel's conclusion: "Yes, the Service may determine the intentional disregard penalty under Section 6721(e) against Company A because the facts suggest it knowingly or willfully failed to timely file information returns with the Service for Year 5." The standard: "Whether a taxpayer knowingly or willfully fails to timely file an information return is 'determined on the basis of all the facts and circumstances in the particular case.'"
The four factors, as Counsel weighed them
The intentional disregard factors, as the regulation lists them and Counsel applied them: "(i) whether the failure to file timely is part of a pattern of conduct of repeatedly failing to file timely; (ii) whether a correction was promptly made upon discovery of the failure; (iii) whether the taxpayer corrects the failure to file within 30 days of a written request from the Service to file; (iv) whether the failure to timely file penalty is less than the cost of timely filing" (CCA 200941012, citing Treas. Reg. 301.6721-1(f)(3)Treas. Reg. 301.6721-1Treasury regulations, Cornell LII, now (g)(3)).
Pattern. "Since Year 1, Company A has exhibited a pattern of repeatedly failing to timely file its information returns. The Service waived proposed penalties for Years 1 and 2 after Company A showed that it had reasonable cause ... and assured the Service that remedial measures were taken to ensure future compliance. These remedial measures were apparently not taken or were inadequate as evidenced by Company A's subsequent late filings." A granted waiver becomes evidence against the filer when the promised fix does not happen.
Prompt correction and the 30-day request. The IRS's emails and letter were ignored for months: the returns came "more than 5 months after the May 2nd e-mail and 3 months after the July 7th letter." Informal contacts from the FIRE unit counted as written requests.
Cost of compliance versus penalty. "The fact that Company A was able to timely file after experiencing such a large increase in volume strongly suggests that Company A could have timely filed the Forms 1099 for Year 5 and the prior years had it dedicated the necessary resources," and "its repeated late filing due to insufficient resources appears to be attributable to a financial decision." Then the detail that matters most to payers who prioritise recipient copies: "Company A has stated that it provided its clients with timely Forms 1099 every year even though it was unable to timely report to the Service. This suggests that the information was available and that Company A was able to print and timely mail millions of Forms 1099. These actions strongly suggest that Company A could have but chose not to expend the resources necessary to timely file with the Service." Counsel inferred a weighing of costs: "it can be inferred that Company A believed that the cost of losing customers due to late mailings of Forms 1099 was considered greater than the cost of ensuring that its customers timely received their Forms 1099."
The penalty consequence is in the regulation the memo applied, now Treas. Reg. 301.6721-1(g)(4)Treas. Reg. 301.6721-1Treasury regulations, Cornell LII: the per-return caps and the annual maximum "will not apply," and the penalty is "$500 or, if greater, the statutory percentage," which for most 1099s is "10 percent of the aggregate dollar amount of the items required to be reported correctly" (the memo's 5 percent figure reflects the pre-2011 statute). The intentional disregard guide covers the manual's version and the current amounts.
Thirteen older memos on 1099s, TINs and withholding
The IRS posts program manager technical assistance going back to the 1990s at irs.gov/pub/lanoa. Most of it is about other subjects; these thirteen bear on information reporting, TINs, backup withholding and the penalties around them. They are older and some predate the current statute, but each records a position Counsel took and, in several cases, the origin of a rule payers now take for granted. Each carries the standard warning that it may not be used or cited as precedent.
Backup withholding and TINs
- Follow-up questions on backup withholding (PMTA 00035, 1995). Two points. First, backup withholding is not a penalty: “Section 3406(h)(10) of the Code provides that payments subject to withholding under section 3406 shall be treated as if they were wages paid by an employer to an employee,” so a policy against asserting penalties and interest on federal agencies did not shield them from withholding. Second, a race track that collects a TIN and then deliberately skips the W-2G “to encourage the payee to continue gambling” cannot be hit with backup withholding, because the payee furnished a TIN; the remedy is the intentional disregard penalty under 6721(e) and 6722(c), with no annual cap. The W-2G calculator applies the current thresholds.
- Batch matching of taxpayer identification numbers (PMTA 00014, March 17, 1995). Asked whether filers could match “their complete data base, i.e., both pre-existing as well as any newly opened accounts” against IRS records, Counsel answered that section 6103 bars disclosing a payee’s name and TIN except as authorized, that “section 3406(a)(1)(B) contemplates the disclosure of TIN information after the filing of a return, not before,” and that the authority for pre-filing matching rests on the regulation issued under 3406(i), which lets the IRS “notify the payor that a TIN does not match the Service’s records” so the payor can “attempt to obtain a correct TIN before the filing of the related information return.” That is the legal footing of today’s TIN Matching program, and the reason it returns only a match code and never the name the IRS holds.
- Disallowance of credit for withholding when an SSN and ITIN do not match (PMTA 2009-161, Dec. 4, 2009). Where a worker’s W-2 carries someone else’s SSN and the return is filed under an ITIN, the IRS may hold the withholding credit until it verifies the wages were the filer’s: “the IRS is not saying that ITIN holders are not entitled to the credit as a matter of law; rather, the IRS is saying that it does not have sufficient information in its records to determine if the ITIN holder is the ‘recipient.’” For a payer the lesson is the mirror image: withholding reported under a wrong TIN is credited to no one until the IRS sorts it out, which is why a corrected 1099 or W-2G with the right TIN matters to the payee as much as to you.
What is, and is not, reportable
- Information reporting for payments to section 530 workers (PMTA 00635, Sept. 30, 2003). A firm with section 530 relief keeps issuing 1099s: “If the business is entitled to such relief, the issue of worker classification will be discontinued. These workers will continue to receive Form 1099-MISC. However, the fact that the business is entitled to section 530 relief does not imply that the workers are employees.” Counsel noted that reporting the pay as nonemployee compensation leads a worker who is in fact an employee to pay self-employment tax by mistake, and that section 530 “terminates the liability of the business for the employment taxes but has no effect on the workers.” The section 530 guide covers the filing-consistency condition this memo assumes.
- Information returns for timber purchases (PMTA 00208, June 2, 1998). A clean worked example of the merchandise exception. “A payment for the purchase of standing timber under a ‘pay-as-cut’ contract is reportable under § 6050N [royalties, $10], but a fixed-sum purchase payment is not reportable under either § 6050N or § 6041. A payment for timber-cutting services is reportable under § 6041, but a payment for harvested timber is not reportable,” because “the purchase of harvested timber is a purchase of merchandise under § 1.6041-3(d).” A combined invoice for timber and the cutting of it “is considered payment for the delivered timber” and is not reported. The 1099 decision tool applies the same distinctions.
- Filing Forms 1099 for a tax amnesty program (PMTA 00592, Feb. 28, 2003). A state forgiving interest and additions to tax under an amnesty makes no “payment” under section 6041, and a state is not an “applicable entity” under section 6050P, so no Form 1099-MISC or 1099-C is due, “irrespective of the tax consequences to the taxpayer.” Useful whenever a creditor that is not a financial entity asks whether forgiving a charge is a 1099-C event.
Penalties, deposits and periods of limitation
- Reasonable cause for employers using third-party processors (PMTA 00013, March 14, 1995). The memo that ended the IRS practice of waiving the failure-to-deposit penalty whenever a payroll processor had the funds in time. Under United States v. Boyle, “reliance on a Processor, by itself, does not provide reasonable cause regardless of the care with which the employer chooses a Processor”; the employer has reasonable cause “only if the Processor has what amounts to reasonable cause for the failure,” such as equipment destroyed by a natural disaster. “The relinquishment of funds to a Processor does not constitute a deposit of tax,” and even a section 3504 agent leaves the employer “subject to any penalty resulting from the Processor’s failure.” The exception is the bank: a misrouted EFT is excused under Rev. Rul. 94-46 when the employer gave timely, correct instructions with funds on hand. This is the position the reporting agents guide describes for Form 945 deposits.
- Form 8300 penalties and limitations period (PMTA 02014, Oct. 17, 2008). “There is no period of limitations applicable to the assessment of a penalty under section 6722” for failing to furnish the Form 8300 payee statement, because no return starts the clock, though Counsel urged assessment within three years “to the extent practicable.” And on the Form 8300 itself: “The penalty under section 6721 may always be assessed on information returns that contain errors or omissions that relate to taxpayer identification numbers, surnames of payees, and monetary amounts,” because the regulation says those are never inconsequential. The same rule governs every 1099: a wrong TIN is never a de minimis error. See the Form 8300 guide.
- Effect of the section 6651 failure-to-pay penalty on withholding (PMTA 01694, March 11, 2008). When a return shows zero tax and an overstated withholding credit is refunded and later reversed, no failure-to-pay addition applies: “a downward adjustment to a withholding credit does not constitute an adjustment to the amount of tax shown on the return.” Withholding credits are payments, not tax. It is the payee’s side of a wrong box 4.
- Form 872 periods of assessment for income and withholding taxes (PMTA 00053, 1994). Examiners in international cases “should be advised to secure two separate Forms 872 - one for income tax and one for withholding tax - from any taxpayer who has filed a Form 1042,” with the withholding form citing “sections 1441-1442” (and separate versions for section 1445 and Form 8288, and section 1446 and Form 8804). A withholding agent asked to extend the statute should expect, and read, the consent that names the withholding sections; the statute extension guide covers the employment tax version.
Worker classification and signatures
- IRC 7436IRC 7436Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII procedures in Employment Tax Adjustment Program cases (PMTA 00211, June 22, 1998). Because the campus adjustment program “does not involve examinations, and do[es] not result in any determination with respect to whether the taxpayer is entitled to section 530 relief,” unagreed and no-response worker classification cases had to go to the field for examination before a notice of determination could issue, and the IRS “is prohibited from making an assessment of taxes until the taxpayer has been advised of the right to contest the adjustments in Tax Court.” The agreement form had to carry an express waiver of “the restrictions on assessment provided in section 7436(d) and 6213(a).” The Letter 3523 page and the Appeals guide describe where that leads today.
- Referral path of IRC 6050IIRC 6050IInternal Revenue Code, Cornell LII violations involving Forms 8300 (PMTA 00436, April 16, 2001). Criminal Form 8300 cases that “solely” involve a failure to file or a false form go straight to the United States Attorney; a “wholly fictitious” Form 8300 filed with no underlying cash transaction, typically to harass an official, goes through the Tax Division. A reminder that Form 8300 is the one information return with a felony attached under section 7203.
- Faxed signatures for CAWR and FUTA (PMTA 00510, 2001). Counsel approved accepting faxed signatures on employer responses to CP 168 and CP 251 notices and 380C letters, reasoning that “the signer’s act of either transmitting or authorizing the transmission of the FAX could constitute the requisite intent to adopt the FAX signature” and that the question for the IRS is reliability. The thinking carried into the e-signature policy payers now rely on for W-9s and penalty responses.
Twenty more memos from the full archive
In October 2026 all 724 memoranda then posted at irs.gov/pub/lanoa were downloaded and searched for backup withholding, TINs, Forms 1099, W-2 and 8300, and the information return penalties. These are the ones that answer a question payers still ask. Each is advice to an IRS office, not precedent; the value is in seeing how Counsel reads the rule.
Backup withholding, TINs and EINs
- One EIN on the Form 945 and the 1099s (PMTA 2019-10, May 24, 2019). Some payors were “reporting and remitting backup withholding on Form 945 using one EIN, but then filing information returns (Forms 1099 and W-2G) under a different EIN, such as a parent or related entity’s EIN.” Counsel's answer: “The same person is the payor for purposes of information reporting and thus should file information returns using the same name/EIN,” and “No legislative change is necessary to effectuate this requirement.” IRSAC asked for the same rule in 2019; the advisory tracker records the outcome.
- Relief from backup withholding the payee already paid (PMTA 2020-09, April 27, 2020). Because backup withholding is wage withholding by statute (under IRC 3406(h)(10)IRC 3406Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII payments subject to withholding under section 3406 are “treated as if they were wages paid by an employer to an employee”), the IRC 3402(d)IRC 3402Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII relief applies: Form 4670 with a Form 4669 from each payee, and “Those persons filing a Form 4670 for payments subject to backup withholding are also directed to attach a copy of the examination report.” The posted copy includes only part of the attached advice. The procedure is in Forms 4669 and 4670.
- States using TIN Matching (PMTA 2012-07, Feb. 13, 2012). Asked whether states could use the e-Services TIN Matching application for their own tax administration, Counsel found it “legally permissible; whether to implement it is a business decision,” and noted the limit every payer signs: “Just as with any other payer, the Terms of Agreement restrict the States’ usage of the TIN Matching application to inquiries related to backup withholding.”
- A disregarded entity's EIN on the owner's return (PMTA 2016-08, Nov. 5, 2015). The matching problem from the IRS side: “Certain information returns such as Forms 1099 that reflect income earned by a disregarded entity may reflect the entity’s EIN and not the owner’s TIN.” Counsel said forms could require the owner to list the entity's EIN, though leaving it off would not invalidate the return. For a payer the lesson runs the other way: a W-9 from a single-member LLC should carry the owner's name and TIN (the LLC W-9 name rules).
- Refusing an EIN (PMTA 00170, 1997). The IRS should not refuse an EIN merely because a trust looks abusive, but “If the taxpayer fails to fully or correctly complete the Form 58-4, the Service has the authority to deny the taxpayer's request for an EIN” (the scan reads “58-4” for SS-4).
Penalties and filing format
- Paper when e-filing was required (PMTA 2022-05, July 8, 2022). Written for Forms 5330, 4720, 5227, 1042 and 1120-POL under the then-proposed e-file regulations: “A filer that submits a return on paper when required to file electronically has failed to file the return according to the forms and regulations prescribed by the Secretary,” so “the filer may be subject to the addition to tax for failure to timely file under section 6651(a)(1), or 6652(c) if appropriate, absent a showing of reasonable cause.” The same logic underlies the IRC 6721IRC 6721Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII treatment of paper 1099s filed without a waiver (e-file waivers).
- A missing TIN on a Schedule K-1 (Form 1041) (PMTA 2016-07, Nov. 2, 2015). The IRS copy falls under IRC 6723IRC 6723Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII, not 6721, and “There is no inflation adjustment for I.R.C. § 6723IRC 6723Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII”; “That penalty remains at $50 for each failure, not to exceed $100,000.” The beneficiary's copy is a payee statement, so the inflation-adjusted IRC 6722IRC 6722Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII penalty applies to it. A reminder that not every information return penalty is a 6721 penalty.
- What the payee faces when your 1099 is not on the return (PMTA 01249, Oct. 22, 2007). “Regulations expressly state that negligence is strongly indicated where a taxpayer fails to include on an income tax return an amount of income shown on the information return,” so the Automated Underreporter program may propose the IRC 6662IRC 6662Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII penalty. That is why a wrong 1099 produces an angry payee (your 1099 caused a payee's CP2000).
What is reported, and on which form
- Employment settlements and attorneys (PMTA 2009-035, Oct. 22, 2008). A four-step test: the character of the payment, whether it is income, whether it is wages, and how to report it. “If a settlement or judgment payment is income but does not constitute wages, the payment will be subject to reporting under § 6041 on Form 1099-MISC,” while “If the payment is excludable from gross income pursuant to § 104(a)(2) or any other section, there is no reporting required.” Payments to the lawyer are reported “regardless of whether the payment constitutes income to the attorney.” The box numbers in the memo predate the 2020 forms.
- Election workers (PMTA 01079, Aug. 13, 2007). “To the extent the payments must be reported, they must be reported on a Form W-2, not a Form 1099, since election workers are employees.” Useful for any government payer tempted to put small stipends on a 1099.
- Form 1099-C: no netting (PMTA 2009-151, March 12, 2009). Written for USDA's debt relief under the Pigford settlement: “There should not be reporting of “net” amounts on Forms 1099-C”; a later reinstatement needs no new form because “Reinstatement of a loan is not one of the eight identifiable events”; and wrong forms should be corrected “for returns filed within the last three calendar years.”
- Form 1099-C without a discharge (PMTA 00686, undated). “The regulations require creditors to file Form 1099-C when certain "identifiable events" occur, even though there is no formal discharge of indebtedness.” A debtor who later pays may amend the year the income was reported.
- Form 1099-G and state credits (PMTA 2014-017, Sept. 19, 2014). A credit or offset “is considered to be allowed when the liability to pay or credit such amount is admitted by the State or local taxing jurisdiction,” and “It is not reportable in the taxable year that gives rise to the refund, credit or offset.”
- The IRS's own 1099s for erroneous refunds (PMTA 00455, 2001). Counsel's review of IRM 3.17.79IRM 3.17.79Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov: “In situations where the nonrebate erroneous refund is income in the year it is received, a Form 1099-C should not be issued for any year.” The guide to when the IRS is the payer gives the rule the manual follows today.
- Whistleblower awards to nonresident aliens (PMTA 2011-02, March 22, 2011). “The Office must withhold tax under section 1441 on the U.S. source portion of the award payment it makes to an NRA whistleblower unless exempted by a U.S. income tax treaty,” and “no provision of the Code or regulations exempts a withholding agent from withholding on a payment simply because the source of that income cannot be determined.” The second sentence applies to every withholding agent.
W-2s and statements with the wrong TIN
- A W-2 filed under someone else's SSN (PMTA 2009-024, June 8, 2008; AM 2017-004, July 8, 2016). A W-2 the employer filed with a stolen SSN the worker supplied is a real return, not a nullity: “Although the employer may be subject to a penalty (if the employer did not have reasonable cause for including the wrong SSN), the Form W-2 cannot be characterized as invalid.” The IRS may tell the employer, but only so much: “The Service may inform the employer that the name and SSN do not match, but the Service may not inform the employer of the identity of the true owner of the SSN.”
- Correcting W-2s after an employment tax exam (PMTA 2018-15, June 25, 2018). The employer that pays withholding it failed to collect does not create more wages for the earlier year: “An employer’s payment of taxes that should have been withheld in a prior year does not create additional wages to the employee for the prior year.” It files a W-2c adding the unreported benefit, but “no amount should be reported by the employer in box 2.” Counsel called the contrary statement in GCM 39577 “in error.”
- A Form 8805 with a wrong TIN (PMTA 00563, Sept. 12, 2002). The foreign partner's return is valid, but “The return is not in processible form for purposes of section 6611 of the Code,” so refund interest waits for a matching statement. Details are in section 1446 withholding inside the IRS.
Three memos on Form 8300 (PMTA 2014-013, 2014-014 and 2018-11) are summarized in the Form 8300 guide.
Recent written determinations, 2023 to 2026
Private letter rulings and Chief Counsel advice are released with identifying details removed under IRC 6110IRC 6110Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII, and by statute they “may not be used or cited as precedent” (IRC 6110(k)(3))IRC 6110Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII. The weekly indexes for 2023 through October 2026 were searched for the payer Code sections (3401 to 3406, 6041 to 6051, 6721 to 6724); these are the determinations that say something a payer can use.
- The 1099-R due date belongs to Congress (CCA 202346011 and 202346012, emails of May 17, 2022, released Nov. 17, 2023). Asked about an earlier deadline for Form 1099-R: “6071(b) uses prescriptive language: “returns… shall be filed on or before March 31”,” so “the Service cannot apply an earlier deadline without legislation.” Extensions on Form 8809 remain: “But the deadline itself could not be changed.” ETAAC has asked Congress for January 31 since 2021.
- No 1099 when the payment is not income (PLRs 202409009 to 202409013, released March 1, 2024). Five identical rulings for a state air district paying low-income residents to retire polluting vehicles, through dealers or prepaid cards. The payments fall under the general welfare exclusion, and because “Section 1.6041–1(f)(1) provides that the section 6041 information reporting requirement applies to payments that are “includible in the gross income of the payee”,” “the Taxpayer does not have an information reporting requirement with respect to the incentive payments under section 6041(a) of the Code.”
- Difficulty-of-care payments go in W-2 box 12, code II (PLRs 202536026, June 4, 2025, and 202610003, Dec. 9, 2025). Medicaid home-care payments excludable under IRC 131IRC 131Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII “are not reportable under section 6041 or 6051 as wages subject to tax and income tax withholding,” but “Taxpayer is required to report payments that are excludable from an individual care provider’s gross income in box 12 of Form W-2 with code II,” and FICA and FUTA may still apply.
- A reporting ruling revoked, prospectively (PLR 202318001, Feb. 6, 2023). The IRS withdrew the part of an earlier ruling on a company's IRC 6041IRC 6041Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII reporting for payments to one payee as “not in accord with the current views of the IRS,” but “Taxpayer is not required to correct any information returns filed with respect to payments made to X prior to the date of this revocation.” A ruling protects the years it covered.
How to use them
- Stop treating the CP2100 as the start of exposure for missing TINs. Under PMTA 2023-03 and the regulation, the exposure began with the first payment made without a TIN. The response to a Letter 6112 or an examination should address those payments on their own terms, through Forms 4669 and 4670 and the W-9 dates, not by pointing to the B-Notice.
- Keep the two conditions apart in your records. A payee with no TIN and a payee with a notified incorrect TIN have different start dates and different stopping rules; a solicitation log that records which condition applied, and when it ended, is what the examiner reconstructs.
- Treat a granted waiver as a promise. Counsel used Company A's own reasonable-cause letters, and the waivers they won, as evidence of a pattern when the next year was late. A response that says the problem is fixed should be true.
- Answer the IRS's informal contacts. Emails from the e-help desk and processing letters were treated as written requests under the 30-day factor. Silence for months is itself a fact.
- Do not let recipient copies go out while the IRS file waits. Timely payee statements with late IRS filing was read as proof that the data existed and the filer chose where to spend. File both.
Questions people ask
Can we cite PMTA 2023-03 in a dispute with the IRS?
You can quote it as the IRS's stated position, which the manual has adopted; it has no precedential force for or against you. It is more useful for understanding what the examiner will compute than for arguing against it.
Does complying with a CP2100 protect us from anything?
Yes: it ends the incorrect-TIN condition once a certified TIN arrives, it satisfies the solicitation requirement that reasonable cause for the penalty depends on (Treas. Reg. 301.6724-1(f)(3))Treas. Reg. 301.6724-1Treasury regulations, Cornell LII, and it is the record the examiner tests. It does not reach back to payments made before the notice, and it does not touch a missing-TIN obligation at all.
Our 1099s were late one year because of a system migration. Is that intentional disregard?
One late year with a prompt correction and no history is the opposite of the pattern Counsel found. The factors are cumulative: repetition, ignoring requests, correcting late, and evidence that filing was a cost decision. The regulation's reasonable-cause route in 301.6724-1 is where a single explicable failure belongs.