Line 4: Permanent residence addressRequiredThe address in the country where the individual claims residence for that country's income tax, determined as the treaty requires; with no tax residence anywhere, where the individual normally resides. A student or researcher whose treaty looks to residence at or immediately before entry may give a U.S. address here, and names that treaty country on line 12a or 13b.Where it goes wrongA financial institution's address, a P.O. box or an address used solely for mailing.Open the line in the tableLine Tax year: Calendar year, or other tax year beginning and endingRequiredThe tax year the exemption covers, entered in the space above Part I. A separate Form 8233 is needed for each tax year, each withholding agent and each type of income.Where it goes wrongLeft blank, or last year's form relied on for a new year.Open the line in the tableLine 5: Address in the United StatesRequiredThe individual's street address in the United States, with city, state and ZIP code.Where it goes wrongA P.O. box, which the form does not allow.Open the line in the tableLine 10: Foreign student, trainee, professor/teacher, or researcherCheckboxIf a student, trainee, teacher or researcher. Check the box and attach the required statement. The format and contents of the statements are in Publication 519, Appendix A and Appendix B.Where it goes wrongBox checked with no statement attached.Open the line in the tableLine 6: U.S. visa typeRequiredThe U.S. visa type: students usually hold an "F-1", professors, teachers and researchers a "J-1", and business or vocational trainees an "M-1" (some "J-1"). With no visa, or none needed, write "None". The IRS processing manual also accepts a blank line 6 from a resident of Canada or Mexico with a Border Crossing Card or a person with a permanent visa waiver (IRM 21.8.6.4(10) Note).Where it goes wrongSpouses and dependents on secondary visas (such as F-2, J-2, H-4 and O-3) are usually not eligible for the primary visa holder's treaty benefits.Open the line in the tableLine 1: Name of individual who is the beneficial ownerRequiredThe complete name of the nonresident alien individual who is the beneficial owner of the income. A person receiving the income as a nominee, agent or custodian is not the beneficial owner.Open the line in the tableLine 8: Date of entry into the United StatesRequiredThe date of entry that relates to the current nonimmigrant status, for example the arrival date on the CBP I-94 record. If the treaty benefit depends on more than one arrival date, enter the earlier date.Open the line in the tableLine 7b: Passport numberRequiredIf not a citizen of Canada or Mexico. The passport number. Not required for citizens of Canada or Mexico. The IRS processing manual lists a third group that need not give a passport number on line 7b: American Indians born in Canada (IRM 21.8.6.4.2(1)).Open the line in the tableLine 3: Foreign tax identification number, if anyIf applicableThe tax identification number issued by the country of residence for tax purposes, if it issued one (for a resident of Canada, the Social Insurance Number).Open the line in the tableLine 9b: Date your current nonimmigrant status expiresRequiredThe date the current nonimmigrant status expires, for example from the CBP I-94 record. Enter "DS" if it is based on duration of status.Open the line in the tableLine 7a: Country issuing passportRequiredIf not a citizen of Canada or Mexico. The country that issued the individual's passport. Citizens of Canada or Mexico are not required to complete lines 7a and 7b.Open the line in the tableLine 2: U.S. taxpayer identification numberRequiredA U.S. TIN must be given: an SSN in most cases, or an ITIN (applied for on Form W-7 with the required documentation) if the individual is not eligible for an SSN. If a number has been applied for but not received, a copy of the completed Form W-7 or SS-5 may be attached.Where it goes wrongAn ITIN expires after 3 consecutive tax years with no tax return filed, and an expired ITIN must be renewed.Open the line in the tableLine 9a: Current nonimmigrant statusRequiredThe current nonimmigrant status, for example as shown on the CBP I-94 record.Open the line in the tableHover over a line for what belongs there and where it goes wrong; click to open the line in the table below. On a touch screen, tap the line to jump to the row.
Line 14: Sufficient facts to justify the exemption from withholding claimed on line 12 and/or line 13RequiredEnough facts and detail for the IRS to determine the treaty benefit claimed on line 12 or 13.Where it goes wrongA form not completed in sufficient detail is an incorrect Form 8233, and the IRS will tell the withholding agent to begin withholding.Open the line in the tablePart III: CertificationRequiredUnder penalties of perjury, the individual is the beneficial owner (or authorized to sign for the beneficial owner), is not a U.S. person, and is (or, as the treaty requires, was at or immediately before entry) a resident of the treaty country on line 12a or 13b. It also authorizes the form to be given to any withholding agent for the income.Open the line in the tableLine 13a: Noncompensatory scholarship or fellowship income: amountRequiredIf claiming a scholarship exemption. The amount of noncompensatory scholarship or fellowship income. Lines 13a to 13d are completed only if the individual also receives compensation for personal services from the same withholding agent and claims a treaty exemption for both.Where it goes wrongScholarship income with no services pay from the same agent belongs on Form W-8BEN, not Form 8233.Open the line in the tableLine 11a: Description of personal services you are providingRequiredDescribe the services, for example "consulting contract to design software" or "give three lectures at XYZ University"; for a student, "part-time library assistant".Open the line in the tableLine Address: Address; city, state, and ZIP codeRequiredThe withholding agent's street address (with apt. or suite no. or P.O. box, if applicable), city, state and ZIP code.Open the line in the tablePart IV: Withholding agent's certificationRequiredThe agent certifies it has examined the form and attachments, is satisfied an exemption is warranted, and does not know or have reason to know the individual is not entitled or that eligibility cannot be readily determined (for example, a fixed base or permanent establishment in the United States). If that changes after acceptance, the agent must promptly notify the IRS and withhold on amounts not yet paid.Where it goes wrongAccepting the form when the agent knows or has reason to know a fact on it may be false; the agent must refuse it and withhold.Open the line in the tableSignature: Signature of beneficial owner (or individual authorized to sign for beneficial owner), dateRequiredSigned and dated by the beneficial owner or an individual authorized to sign for the beneficial owner.Open the line in the tableLine 12a: Tax treaty on which you are basing exemption from withholdingRequiredThe specific treaty the exemption is based on, for example the United States and Germany income tax treaty.Where it goes wrongA country with which the United States has no ratified tax treaty.Open the line in the tableLine Name: Withholding agent's nameRequiredThe withholding agent's name. The agent completes Part IV only if, based on the facts presented, it is satisfied the exemption is warranted.Open the line in the tableSignature: Signature of withholding agent, dateRequiredSigned and dated by the withholding agent or its authorized agent (Regulations section 1.1441-7(c)). Make three copies with attachments: one to the individual, one kept, and one sent to the IRS (Philadelphia, PA 19255-0725, or fax 267-941-1365) within 5 days of acceptance.Where it goes wrongThe exemption applies back to the first payment covered, but the agent must wait at least 10 days after mailing the form to see whether the IRS objects.Open the line in the tableLine 11b: Total compensation you expect to be paid for these services in this calendar or tax yearRequiredThe total compensation for personal services from this withholding agent for the tax year; an estimate if the exact amount is not known.Open the line in the tableLine 12b: Treaty article on which you are basing exemption from withholdingRequiredThe specific article of that treaty, for example "Article 14, paragraph 2" or "Article 7 (business profits)". A resident claiming exemption under a services permanent establishment provision (such as Article 5, paragraph 9, of the Canada treaty) enters that provision.Where it goes wrongA treaty benefit that does not exist in the individual's treaty.Open the line in the tableLine 12c: Total compensation listed on line 11b that is exempt from tax under this treatyRequiredWrite "All" if all the income for the services covered by the form is exempt; otherwise the exact dollar amount that is exempt.Open the line in the tableLine 12d: Country of residenceRequiredThe treaty country of residence. A claim under the employment or independent services (business profits) article requires residence in that country; a student, trainee, teacher or researcher article generally requires only residence at the time of, or immediately before, entry.Open the line in the tableLine 13b: Tax treaty on which you are basing exemption from withholdingRequiredIf claiming a scholarship exemption. The specific treaty the scholarship or fellowship exemption is based on.Open the line in the tableLine 13c: Treaty article on which you are basing exemption from withholdingRequiredIf claiming a scholarship exemption. The specific article of the treaty on line 13b, for example "Article 20, paragraph 3".Open the line in the tableLine 13d: Total income listed on line 13a that is exempt from tax under this treatyRequiredIf claiming a scholarship exemption. The part of the line 13a amount that is exempt under the treaty.Open the line in the tableLine Telephone: Telephone numberRequiredThe withholding agent's telephone number.Open the line in the tableLine EIN: Employer identification numberRequiredThe withholding agent's EIN. Section 6109 requires withholding agents to provide their identification numbers.Open the line in the tableWho completes it and who asks for it
A nonresident alien individual who is paid for personal services performed in the United States, and claims that a tax treaty exempts some or all of that pay from withholding, completes Form 8233 and gives it to the payer. It covers pay for independent personal services (a consultant, speaker or performer working as a contractor), certain dependent personal services (wages a treaty exempts, most often for students, trainees, teachers and researchers), and noncompensatory scholarship or fellowship income, the last only when the same withholding agent also pays the person for services.
It is the wrong form when the payee is not claiming a treaty exemption for services pay (an employee completes Form W-4 under the nonresident alien rules; a contractor gives a W-8BEN and is withheld on at 30%), when the only income is a noncompensatory scholarship (W-8BEN), or when the income is not pay for personal services at all, such as royalties (W-8BEN). Pay for services performed entirely outside the United States is foreign-source and needs no treaty claim.
A separate Form 8233 is required for each tax year, each withholding agent and each type of income. A visiting professor who also lectures at other institutions gives a separate form to each one.
Line by line
Every line of Form 8233 (Rev. September 2018), in form order, with what goes on it and where it goes wrong, from the Instructions for Form 8233 (Rev. December 2025).
| Tax year | ||
| Tax yearCalendar year, or other tax year beginning and endingRequiredThe tax year the exemption covers, entered in the space above Part I. A separate Form 8233 is needed for each tax year, each withholding agent and each type of income.Where it goes wrongLeft blank, or last year's form relied on for a new year. | ||
| Part I. Identification of Beneficial Owner | ||
| 1Name of individual who is the beneficial ownerRequiredThe complete name of the nonresident alien individual who is the beneficial owner of the income. A person receiving the income as a nominee, agent or custodian is not the beneficial owner. | ||
| 2U.S. taxpayer identification numberRequiredA U.S. TIN must be given: an SSN in most cases, or an ITIN (applied for on Form W-7 with the required documentation) if the individual is not eligible for an SSN. If a number has been applied for but not received, a copy of the completed Form W-7 or SS-5 may be attached.Where it goes wrongAn ITIN expires after 3 consecutive tax years with no tax return filed, and an expired ITIN must be renewed. | ||
| 3Foreign tax identification number, if anyIf applicableThe tax identification number issued by the country of residence for tax purposes, if it issued one (for a resident of Canada, the Social Insurance Number). | ||
| 4Permanent residence addressRequiredThe address in the country where the individual claims residence for that country's income tax, determined as the treaty requires; with no tax residence anywhere, where the individual normally resides. A student or researcher whose treaty looks to residence at or immediately before entry may give a U.S. address here, and names that treaty country on line 12a or 13b.Where it goes wrongA financial institution's address, a P.O. box or an address used solely for mailing. | ||
| 5Address in the United StatesRequiredThe individual's street address in the United States, with city, state and ZIP code.Where it goes wrongA P.O. box, which the form does not allow. | ||
| 6U.S. visa typeRequiredThe U.S. visa type: students usually hold an "F-1", professors, teachers and researchers a "J-1", and business or vocational trainees an "M-1" (some "J-1"). With no visa, or none needed, write "None". The IRS processing manual also accepts a blank line 6 from a resident of Canada or Mexico with a Border Crossing Card or a person with a permanent visa waiver (IRM 21.8.6.4(10) Note)IRM 21.8.6.4(10) NoteInternal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.Where it goes wrongSpouses and dependents on secondary visas (such as F-2, J-2, H-4 and O-3) are usually not eligible for the primary visa holder's treaty benefits. | ||
| 7aCountry issuing passportRequiredIf not a citizen of Canada or Mexico. The country that issued the individual's passport. Citizens of Canada or Mexico are not required to complete lines 7a and 7b. | ||
| 7bPassport numberRequiredIf not a citizen of Canada or Mexico. The passport number. Not required for citizens of Canada or Mexico. The IRS processing manual lists a third group that need not give a passport number on line 7b: American Indians born in Canada (IRM 21.8.6.4.2(1))IRM 21.8.6.4.2(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. | ||
| 8Date of entry into the United StatesRequiredThe date of entry that relates to the current nonimmigrant status, for example the arrival date on the CBP I-94 record. If the treaty benefit depends on more than one arrival date, enter the earlier date. | ||
| 9aCurrent nonimmigrant statusRequiredThe current nonimmigrant status, for example as shown on the CBP I-94 record. | ||
| 9bDate your current nonimmigrant status expiresRequiredThe date the current nonimmigrant status expires, for example from the CBP I-94 record. Enter "DS" if it is based on duration of status. | ||
| 10Foreign student, trainee, professor/teacher, or researcherCheckboxIf a student, trainee, teacher or researcher. Check the box and attach the required statement. The format and contents of the statements are in Publication 519, Appendix A and Appendix B.Where it goes wrongBox checked with no statement attached. | ||
| Part II. Claim for Tax Treaty Withholding Exemption | ||
| 11aDescription of personal services you are providingRequiredDescribe the services, for example "consulting contract to design software" or "give three lectures at XYZ University"; for a student, "part-time library assistant". | ||
| 11bTotal compensation you expect to be paid for these services in this calendar or tax yearRequiredThe total compensation for personal services from this withholding agent for the tax year; an estimate if the exact amount is not known. | ||
| 12aTax treaty on which you are basing exemption from withholdingRequiredThe specific treaty the exemption is based on, for example the United States and Germany income tax treaty.Where it goes wrongA country with which the United States has no ratified tax treaty. | ||
| 12bTreaty article on which you are basing exemption from withholdingRequiredThe specific article of that treaty, for example "Article 14, paragraph 2" or "Article 7 (business profits)". A resident claiming exemption under a services permanent establishment provision (such as Article 5, paragraph 9, of the Canada treaty) enters that provision.Where it goes wrongA treaty benefit that does not exist in the individual's treaty. | ||
| 12cTotal compensation listed on line 11b that is exempt from tax under this treatyRequiredWrite "All" if all the income for the services covered by the form is exempt; otherwise the exact dollar amount that is exempt. | ||
| 12dCountry of residenceRequiredThe treaty country of residence. A claim under the employment or independent services (business profits) article requires residence in that country; a student, trainee, teacher or researcher article generally requires only residence at the time of, or immediately before, entry. | ||
| 13aNoncompensatory scholarship or fellowship income: amountRequiredIf claiming a scholarship exemption. The amount of noncompensatory scholarship or fellowship income. Lines 13a to 13d are completed only if the individual also receives compensation for personal services from the same withholding agent and claims a treaty exemption for both.Where it goes wrongScholarship income with no services pay from the same agent belongs on Form W-8BEN, not Form 8233. | ||
| 13bTax treaty on which you are basing exemption from withholdingRequiredIf claiming a scholarship exemption. The specific treaty the scholarship or fellowship exemption is based on. | ||
| 13cTreaty article on which you are basing exemption from withholdingRequiredIf claiming a scholarship exemption. The specific article of the treaty on line 13b, for example "Article 20, paragraph 3". | ||
| 13dTotal income listed on line 13a that is exempt from tax under this treatyRequiredIf claiming a scholarship exemption. The part of the line 13a amount that is exempt under the treaty. | ||
| 14Sufficient facts to justify the exemption from withholding claimed on line 12 and/or line 13RequiredEnough facts and detail for the IRS to determine the treaty benefit claimed on line 12 or 13.Where it goes wrongA form not completed in sufficient detail is an incorrect Form 8233, and the IRS will tell the withholding agent to begin withholding. | ||
| Part III. Certification | ||
| Part IIICertificationRequiredUnder penalties of perjury, the individual is the beneficial owner (or authorized to sign for the beneficial owner), is not a U.S. person, and is (or, as the treaty requires, was at or immediately before entry) a resident of the treaty country on line 12a or 13b. It also authorizes the form to be given to any withholding agent for the income. | ||
| SignatureSignature of beneficial owner (or individual authorized to sign for beneficial owner), dateRequiredSigned and dated by the beneficial owner or an individual authorized to sign for the beneficial owner. | ||
| Part IV. Withholding Agent Acceptance and Certification | ||
| NameWithholding agent's nameRequiredThe withholding agent's name. The agent completes Part IV only if, based on the facts presented, it is satisfied the exemption is warranted. | ||
| EINEmployer identification numberRequiredThe withholding agent's EIN. Section 6109 requires withholding agents to provide their identification numbers. | ||
| AddressAddress; city, state, and ZIP codeRequiredThe withholding agent's street address (with apt. or suite no. or P.O. box, if applicable), city, state and ZIP code. | ||
| TelephoneTelephone numberRequiredThe withholding agent's telephone number. | ||
| Part IVWithholding agent's certificationRequiredThe agent certifies it has examined the form and attachments, is satisfied an exemption is warranted, and does not know or have reason to know the individual is not entitled or that eligibility cannot be readily determined (for example, a fixed base or permanent establishment in the United States). If that changes after acceptance, the agent must promptly notify the IRS and withhold on amounts not yet paid.Where it goes wrongAccepting the form when the agent knows or has reason to know a fact on it may be false; the agent must refuse it and withhold. | ||
| SignatureSignature of withholding agent, dateRequiredSigned and dated by the withholding agent or its authorized agent (Regulations section 1.1441-7(c))Treas. Reg. 1.1441-7Treasury regulations, Cornell LII. Make three copies with attachments: one to the individual, one kept, and one sent to the IRS (Philadelphia, PA 19255-0725, or fax 267-941-1365) within 5 days of acceptance.Where it goes wrongThe exemption applies back to the first payment covered, but the agent must wait at least 10 days after mailing the form to see whether the IRS objects. |
What the withholding agent relies on
The agent reviews the form and, if satisfied that the exemption is warranted, signs the acceptance in Part IV. It makes three copies, each with every attachment: one for the individual, one for its records, and one for the IRS, sent within 5 days of acceptance to Department of the Treasury, Internal Revenue Service, Philadelphia, PA 19255-0725, or by fax to 267-941-1365 (up to 25 pages at a time).
The exemption applies back to the first payment the form covers, but the agent must wait at least 10 days after properly mailing it to see whether the IRS objects. If the IRS objects, or later tells the agent that eligibility is in doubt, the agent withholds on amounts not yet paid.
The agent must not accept the form, and must withhold, if it knows or has reason to know that any statement on it may be false, or that eligibility cannot be readily determined, for example because the person has a fixed base or permanent establishment in the United States. If it learns this after accepting, it notifies the IRS in writing and starts withholding on amounts not yet paid.
Without an accepted Form 8233, pay for independent personal services performed in the United States is subject to 30% withholding, and wages for dependent services follow the wage-withholding rules on a Form W-4. Treaty-exempt payments are still reported on Form 1042-S.
What the IRS sends back
The IRS copy is worked by a unit at the Philadelphia campus under IRM 21.8.6IRM 21.8.6Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The unit enters the form in a database and answers the withholding agent by letter. “Letter 4070 is the approval letter and letter 4071 is the Checklist Rejection letter” (IRM 21.8.6.5(2))IRM 21.8.6.5(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A rejection comes back with the form itself: “A Form 8233 that is either incorrect or incomplete is rejected and returned to the withholding agent with IDRS Letter 3383C, or Letter 4071C” (IRM 21.8.6.4(8))IRM 21.8.6.4(8)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The letters carry the agent’s name, address and TIN, the individual’s name and TIN, the tax year and an IRS contact. The database also gives each form a 10-digit control number that begins with the tax year, which is the number to quote if you call or write about a letter (IRM 21.8.6.5(3))IRM 21.8.6.5(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
IRM 21.8.6.4(7)IRM 21.8.6.4(7)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov and (8); 21.8.6.5(2). The manual sets no number of days for the IRS review; the only clock in it is the agent's 10 days.
A rejection changes what you do with the very next payment. “Upon receipt of the 3383C, or 4071C and Form 8233, the withholding agent is responsible to begin withholding at the 30 percent statutory rate. This means the withholding agent must withhold tax on any payments made to the foreign person, both now and in the future, or until a corrected Form 8233 is received and approved by the IRS” (IRM 21.8.6.4(8))IRM 21.8.6.4(8)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The manual states one rate for every case; where the pay is wages, the wage withholding rules described above apply. The cure is a corrected Form 8233 that the IRS approves. A rejection can also come after the waiting period has run: “If the IRS rejects Form 8233 after the minimum 10- day waiting period, then the withholding agent, after receiving written information from the IRS, must withhold tax at the statutory rate of 30 percent” (IRM 21.8.6.4(7))IRM 21.8.6.4(7)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
What gets a form rejected at the IRS
Incomplete is read literally. The database lists every required field that is empty, and “Unless the user is able to immediately correct the field, Form 8233 is rejected” (IRM 21.8.6.5(3))IRM 21.8.6.5(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A blank mandatory line produces a rejection letter, not a phone call. The manual marks these fields as mandatory (IRM 21.8.6.6.1.1IRM 21.8.6.6.1.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov to 21.8.6.6.1.3): the SSN or ITIN, the first and last name, one line of the foreign address and the foreign city, the U.S. address with city, state and ZIP code, the visa type, the passport country and number, the date of arrival, the nonimmigrant status and its expiry date (or DS), the description of services, the expected pay, the treaty and article, the country of residence, and the agent’s name, address, city and state in Part IV. The database also runs cross-checks you can run first:
| Check before you sign Part IV | The rule in the IRS database | Cite |
|---|---|---|
| Line 14 is filled in whenever line 12 or line 13 has an entry | Supporting facts are “mandatory when an entry is present in any of the following lines: 12a, 12b, 12c, 13a, 13b, or 13c.” | IRM 21.8.6.6.1.2(10)IRM 21.8.6.6.1.2(10)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov |
| Line 12c is not more than line 11b | The exempt amount cannot be greater than the expected pay. Line 12c is mandatory once a treaty article is cited. | IRM 21.8.6.6.1.2(5)IRM 21.8.6.6.1.2(5)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov |
| Line 13d is not more than line 13a | The same test for scholarship or fellowship income. | IRM 21.8.6.6.1.2(9)IRM 21.8.6.6.1.2(9)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov |
| Line 12d names the treaty country | The country of residence must be the country of the treaty cited on lines 12a and 12b. | IRM 21.8.6.6.1.2(6)IRM 21.8.6.6.1.2(6)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov |
| Line 10 checked means a statement is attached | The statement field must be answered yes when line 10 is checked. | IRM 21.8.6.6.1.1(24)IRM 21.8.6.6.1.1(24)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov |
Two entries that look like gaps are allowed. A resident of Canada or Mexico with a Border Crossing Card, or a person with a permanent visa waiver, may leave line 6 blank or write NONE (IRM 21.8.6.4(10) Note)IRM 21.8.6.4(10) NoteInternal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. And the manual lists three groups that “are not required to write their passport number on Line 7b of Form 8233”: Canadians, Mexicans and American Indians born in Canada (IRM 21.8.6.4.2(1))IRM 21.8.6.4.2(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The form instructions name only citizens of Canada and Mexico.
The received date, old revisions and how long the IRS keeps the form
- The postmark is the IRS received date. “Use the postmark date of the envelope as the IRS received date.” With no postmark, or a postage meter date, the unit uses the date the agent signed Part IV plus one day (IRM 21.8.6.4(7) Reminder)IRM 21.8.6.4(7) ReminderInternal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Mail the copy the day you sign and keep proof of mailing.
- Old revisions. The unit is told “Do not accept any Form 8233 with a revision date prior to March 2009” (IRM 21.8.6.4(5) Reminder)IRM 21.8.6.4(5) ReminderInternal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. That is a floor for the IRS, not advice: use the September 2018 form.
- Six years. Accepted paper forms are boxed and stored, and “They are destroyed when 6 years old” (IRM 21.8.6.4(9))IRM 21.8.6.4(9)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The database records “are held in retention for six years before being purged” (IRM 21.8.6.5(1))IRM 21.8.6.5(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. After that the only copy is yours.
Where these go wrong
- A W-8BEN treaty claim for U.S. services. The W-8BEN cannot claim a treaty exemption for pay for services performed in the United States. It documents foreign status; without a Form 8233 the pay is withheld on at 30%.
- Last year's form. Form 8233 covers one tax year. A contractor who returns in January needs a new one before the first payment.
- A fixed base in the United States. A person with an office or fixed base regularly available in the U.S. generally cannot claim the independent personal services or business profits exemption; a few treaties have limited exceptions.
- Day counts and dollar caps. Many articles end the exemption once the person passes a number of days in the U.S. or a dollar amount for the year. When that happens mid-year, withholding starts on the payments that follow.
- No IRS copy. An accepted form that was never sent to the IRS within 5 days, or payments made without waiting out the 10 days.
- Paying on after a rejection letter. Once Letter 3383C or 4071C arrives with the returned form, every payment is withheld on until a corrected Form 8233 is approved (IRM 21.8.6.4(8))IRM 21.8.6.4(8)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Filing the letter and paying as before leaves the agent liable for the tax.
- A claim based on the daily personal exemption. Older procedures let a nonresident reduce withholding on services pay by a daily personal exemption amount. The personal exemption is zero for tax years after December 31, 2017 (IRC 151(d)(5))IRC 151Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII, and the IRS manual says “nonresident aliens can no longer claim an exemption from withholding on compensation for independent and certain dependent personal services based on the daily personal exemption amount” (IRM 21.8.6.4(1) Note)IRM 21.8.6.4(1) NoteInternal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Only a treaty exemption works on this form.
- Services performed abroad. A form collected for work done entirely outside the United States. That pay is foreign-source; a W-8BEN documents status and nothing is withheld or reported.
Questions people ask about Form 8233
Is Form 8233 filed with the IRS?
Yes, unlike the W-8 series. The withholding agent sends a copy within 5 days of accepting it. The individual does not file it.
Can a foreign contractor working in the U.S. use a W-8BEN instead?
Not to claim a treaty exemption for that pay. The W-8BEN establishes foreign status only; without an accepted Form 8233 the agent withholds 30%.
How long is it valid?
One tax year, for one withholding agent and one type of income. A new form is needed each year and for each payer.
The payee has no SSN or ITIN yet. Can we accept it?
The form requires a U.S. TIN. If the person has applied, they can attach a copy of the filed Form W-7 or SS-5 showing the application. The IRS manual tells its staff to log such a form under a placeholder number when no TIN has been provided (IRM 21.8.6.6.1.1(3) Note)IRM 21.8.6.6.1.1(3) NoteInternal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
Does the IRS tell us whether it approved the form?
Yes. The IRS manual names Letter 4070 as the approval letter. A form that is incorrect or incomplete is returned with Letter 3383C or 4071C, and the agent then withholds on every payment until a corrected Form 8233 is approved (IRM 21.8.6.4(8) and 21.8.6.5(2))IRM 21.8.6.4(8)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 21.8.6.5(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The manual sets no number of days for the IRS review.
Does a treaty exemption mean nothing is reported?
No. Treaty-exempt pay is reported on Form 1042-S, and the individual may still have to file a U.S. return.
The other certification forms
W-9 · W-9(SP) · W-9S · W-8BEN · W-8BEN-E · W-8ECI · W-8EXP · W-8IMY · W-8CE · W-4P · W-4R · 5754 · Comparison table
See also: Form 8802 and Form 6166: proving your own U.S. residency abroad.
Sources: Form 8233 (Rev. September 2018); Instructions for Form 8233 (Rev. December 2025); Publication 515; Publication 519, Appendices A and B; Publication 901; Treas. Reg. 1.1441-4(b)Treas. Reg. 1.1441-4Treasury regulations, Cornell LII; IRM 21.8.6IRM 21.8.6Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, Exemptions from US Withholding (Form 8233) (Sept. 22, 2026).