TIN ComplianceA resource from TIN Comply

E-Verify for employers: requirements, the three-day rule and mismatches

E-Verify is a free online system, run by the Department of Homeland Security with the Social Security Administration, that compares the information on a new hire’s Form I-9 with government records to confirm the person may work in the United States. Most employers are not required to use it. Federal contractors with the E-Verify clause in their contract are, and so are employers covered by some state laws. An employer that enrolls takes on firm rules: a case for every new hire by the third business day, no checks on applicants, and no action against an employee over a mismatch while it is being resolved.

What E-Verify checks

A mismatch is not a result. The employee keeps working while it is resolved. Only a Final Nonconfirmation supports ending employment based on E-Verify.

E-Verify starts from a completed Form I-9. The employer enters the I-9 information, and the system compares it “to records available to the U.S. Department of Homeland Security and the Social Security Administration to confirm employment eligibility.”

It does not replace the I-9. Every employer completes Form I-9 for every new hire. E-Verify is a second step that only enrolled employers take, and the two have different rules:

Form I-9E-Verify
Required?Yes, for every employerVoluntary for most employers
Social Security numberNot requiredRequired
Photo on a List B identity documentNot requiredRequired
Reverifying expired work authorizationDone on the formNot allowed

That last row is in capitals on E-Verify’s own comparison: it “MAY NOT be used to reverify expired employment authorization”. And cases are entered one at a time: “All cases must be created individually.” There is no bulk upload of a payroll file.

Who has to use it

The user manual states the default: “E-Verify is a voluntary program.” It then lists who is not in the default:

  • Federal contractors. “employers with federal contracts or subcontracts that contain the Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) E-Verify clause are required to enroll in and use E-Verify as a condition of federal contracting.”
  • Employers covered by a state law. Some states require E-Verify, for example as a condition of a business license. E-Verify does not give guidance on state or local laws, so check with the state.
  • Employers under a court order.

A contractor with the FAR clause works to its own clock. E-Verify’s federal contractor pages give these time frames: enroll within 30 calendar days of the contract award, begin checking new hires within 90 calendar days of enrolling, and check each existing employee assigned to the contract within 90 calendar days of enrolling or 30 calendar days of the assignment, whichever is later. Contracting officials decide whether a contract carries the clause.

E-Verify, SSNVS and IRS TIN Matching: which check does what

Three federal services check a name against a number. They are not interchangeable, and each one bars uses that belong to another.

IRS TIN MatchingSSNVSE-Verify
Run byIRSSocial Security AdministrationDepartment of Homeland Security (USCIS), with SSA
Who you checkPayees you will report on a 1099: vendors, contractors, account holdersEmployees you will report on a Form W-2Newly hired employees
What it comparesName and TIN (SSN, EIN or ITIN) against IRS recordsName and SSN, and date of birth if you give it, against SSA recordsForm I-9 information against DHS and SSA records
What it answersDoes this name and TIN pair match?Does this name and SSN pair match?Is this person authorized to work in the United States?
WhenBefore you file the information returnAfter hire, for wage reportingBy the third business day after the employee starts work for pay
Required?NoNoNo for most employers. Yes under some federal contracts and state laws
Form it supportsForm W-9 and the 1099 seriesForm W-4 and Form W-2Form I-9

E-Verify does include a Social Security check. When the name, number or date of birth does not agree with SSA’s records, the case comes back as an SSA mismatch. So an enrolled employer has, in effect, had the name and SSN compared at hire. That does not make E-Verify a payroll tool. It cannot be run on employees hired before you enrolled, and it cannot be run on contractors at all. To check a whole payroll file before W-2s go out, the service is SSNVS. To check contractors and vendors before 1099s go out, it is IRS TIN Matching.

The rules an enrolled employer agrees to

Enrollment means signing a memorandum of understanding with DHS, and the duties start that day. For an employer account: “You must begin using E-Verify for all new hires on the date you electronically sign the memorandum of understanding (MOU).”

You must:

  • Display the Notice of E-Verify Participation and the Right to Work poster, in English and Spanish, where applicants and employees will see them.
  • Complete Form I-9 for each new hire, and then create the case. The deadline is fixed: “Create a case for each newly hired employee no later than the third business day after he or she starts work for pay.”
  • Get an SSN: “Obtain a Social Security number (SSN) from each newly hired employee on Form I-9”.
  • Accept only List B identity documents that carry a photo.
  • Give every employee with a mismatch notice of it and the chance to resolve it.
  • Safeguard the personal information you enter.

You must not:

  • Screen applicants. The manual’s wording is that employers must not “Use E-Verify to pre-screen an applicant for employment.”
  • Tell an employee which I-9 documents to present.
  • Run existing staff. The compliance page lists as a “do not”: “Create cases for employees hired before the employer enrolled in E-Verify”. Certain federal contractors are the exception.
  • Act on a mismatch. Employers must not “Take adverse action against or terminate an employee because he or she received a mismatch result, unless E-Verify issues a case result of Final Nonconfirmation.”
  • Ask people to check themselves. “Employers may not ask current or prosepective employees to use Self Check to prove employment eligibility.” (The spelling is the manual’s.)

When a case comes back as a mismatch

Most cases return “Employment Authorized” within seconds. The one that needs care is the Tentative Nonconfirmation, which E-Verify now calls a mismatch. Start from what it means: “A mismatch does not necessarily mean that the employee is not authorized to work in the United States.”

An SSA mismatch has ordinary causes. E-Verify lists them: citizenship or immigration status not updated with SSA, a name change not reported to SSA, a wrong name, number or date of birth in SSA’s records, or an employer typing error.

StepWhoDeadline
Tell the employee, in private, and give them the Further Action NoticeEmployerAs soon as possible, and “within 10 federal government working days after E-Verify issues the mismatch result”
Decide whether to take action, and sign the noticeEmployeeBy that same 10th working day, or the employer closes the case
Refer the case and give the employee the Referral Date ConfirmationEmployerWhen the employee chooses to take action
Visit an SSA field office (SSA mismatch) or call DHS (DHS mismatch)EmployeeEight federal government working days from the referral
Check the case for the updated result and close itEmployerAfter SSA or DHS updates the case

While this runs, the employee keeps working. “The employee must be allowed to continue working while he or she resolves the mismatch.” You may not delay training, cut hours or take any other adverse step because of it. The point at which E-Verify supports ending employment is stated just as plainly: “Only after an employee receives a DHS or SSA Final Nonconfirmation may the employer terminate the employee based on E-Verify.”

What happens if you misuse it

USCIS monitors how accounts are used. It contacts employers by email and phone, runs desk reviews, and makes site visits. On money, the answer is short: “E-Verify does not fine employers.” But it can end an employer’s participation, with or without notice, and it can refer suspected fraud or discrimination to Immigration and Customs Enforcement or the Department of Justice.

The penalties that carry dollar amounts belong to the laws underneath: the Form I-9 rules and the ban on immigration-related employment discrimination. Enrolling in E-Verify does not change those duties. See Form I-9.

For payroll, the practical gain from E-Verify is cleaner SSNs on day one. For the rest of the workforce, and for the annual wage report, see SSNVS. For the people you pay who are not employees, see worker classification and IRS TIN Matching.

Questions people ask

Is E-Verify mandatory?

Not for most employers. It is required for federal contractors whose contract contains the FAR E-Verify clause, for employers covered by a state law that requires it, and for employers under a court order.

How long do you have to run E-Verify on a new hire?

An enrolled employer must create the case no later than the third business day after the employee starts work for pay. The Form I-9 is completed first.

Can you use E-Verify on job applicants?

No. The E-Verify User Manual says employers must not use E-Verify to pre-screen an applicant for employment.

Can you run E-Verify on existing employees?

Generally no. An employer may not create cases for employees hired before it enrolled. Certain federal contractors with the FAR E-Verify clause are the exception.

Does E-Verify check the Social Security number?

Yes. E-Verify compares the Form I-9 information with records available to SSA and DHS, and a name, number or date of birth that does not agree with SSA's records produces an SSA mismatch. It is still not a replacement for SSNVS, which checks employees for Form W-2 reporting.

Can you fire an employee who gets an E-Verify mismatch?

Not because of the mismatch. The employee must be allowed to keep working while resolving it, and E-Verify says an employer may terminate based on E-Verify only after a Final Nonconfirmation.

Does E-Verify cost anything?

No. E-Verify describes itself as a free internet-based system.