TIN ComplianceA resource from TIN Comply
Notice 972CG · From the IRS manual

The penalties next to your 1099s, and the two that reasonable cause cannot remove

Around the IRC 6721 penalty and its Notice 972CG sits a ring of smaller penalties: the broker notice penalty, the false W-9 penalty, the sub-$10 statement penalty, the Form 8806 penalty, the dishonored EFTPS deposit penalty and the willful W-2 penalty. They are assessed on a different form, billed on a different notice, and for two of them the manual says reasonable cause is not a defense at all. Here is what the Miscellaneous Penalties and International Penalties manuals say about each, and what relief is left.

Updated November 16, 2026Reading time 11 minutesSources IRM 20.1.10 (Aug. 12, 2026); IRM 20.1.9 (Jan. 29, 2021)

No First Time Abate, no oral requests

IRM 20.1.10IRM 20.1.10Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov covers the civil penalties without a chapter of their own, and it opens with two rules for all of them: the first-time abate policy "does not apply to the penalties in this IRM" (IRM 20.1.10.2.2(3))IRM 20.1.10.2.2(3)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Aug. 12, 2026, irs.gov, and "Oral testimony does not apply to the penalties in this IRM" (IRM 20.1.10.2.5)IRM 20.1.10.2.5Internal Revenue Manual, revised Apr. 26, 2018, irs.gov.

"The first-time abate policy does not apply to the penalties in this IRM." "Oral testimony does not apply to the penalties in this IRM" (IRM 20.1.10.2.2(3); IRM 20.1.10.2.5)IRM 20.1.10.2.2(3)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Aug. 12, 2026, irs.govIRM 20.1.10.2.5Internal Revenue Manual, revised Apr. 26, 2018, irs.gov. A phone call cannot remove any penalty on this page, and a clean three-year history is not a defense.

The penalties at a glance

SectionWhat it penalizesAmountPRNRelief route
IRC 6705IRC 6705Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LIIBroker fails to give the payor the 15-day backup withholding notice (IRM 20.1.10.13)IRM 20.1.10.13Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov$500 per failure632No reasonable cause; pay in full, then claim a refund (IRM 20.1.10.13.3)IRM 20.1.10.13.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov
IRC 6674IRC 6674Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LIIWillfully furnishing a false W-2, or willfully failing to furnish one (IRM 20.1.10.9)IRM 20.1.10.9Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov$50 per failure575No reasonable cause; pay in full, then claim a refund (IRM 20.1.10.9.3)IRM 20.1.10.9.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov
IRC 6682IRC 6682Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LIIA payee's W-4 or W-9 statement with "no reasonable basis" (IRM 20.1.10.10)IRM 20.1.10.10Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov$500 per statement616Reasonable basis; waiver if the year's tax is at most credits plus estimated payments (IRM 20.1.10.10.3)IRM 20.1.10.10.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov
IRC 6652(a)IRC 6652Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LIISub-$10 dividend or patronage statement for a payee under backup withholding (IRM 20.1.10.6.1)IRM 20.1.10.6.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov$1 per statement, $1,000 per year590Reasonable cause (IRM 20.1.10.6.1.3)IRM 20.1.10.6.1.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov; no FTA, no oral request
IRC 6652(l)IRC 6652Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LIIForm 8806 and the 1099-CAPs, "considered as one return" (IRM 20.1.10.6.5)IRM 20.1.10.6.5Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov$500 per day, $100,000 maximum649Reasonable cause (IRM 20.1.10.6.5.2)IRM 20.1.10.6.5.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov; no FTA, no oral request
IRC 6657IRC 6657Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LIIA dishonored payment, including an EFTPS deposit for Form 945 or 1042 (IRM 20.1.10.7)IRM 20.1.10.7Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov2% if $1,250 or more; $25 if $25 to $1,249.99TC 280 or 286, no Form 8278Written request only; bank letter for bank error (IRM 20.1.10.7.3)IRM 20.1.10.7.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov; no FTA

IRC 6682IRC 6682Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII falls on the individual who signed the certification, not on the payer that relied on it (IRM 20.1.10.10)IRM 20.1.10.10Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. IRC 6657IRC 6657Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII is assessed by campus accounting from the dishonored-payment transaction (IRM 20.1.10.7.2(1))IRM 20.1.10.7.2(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, so the Form 8278 steps below do not apply to it.

IRC 6705: the broker's 15-day notice

A broker acquiring a readily tradable instrument for a customer "must notify the payor of such instrument within 15 days of the acquisition that the payee is subject to backup withholding if" the payee gave no TIN, the IRS said the TIN is incorrect, the payee has not certified that it is not subject, or the IRS told the broker before the acquisition that the payee is subject (IRM 20.1.10.13(2))IRM 20.1.10.13(2)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Aug. 12, 2026, irs.gov. The notice may go by "magnetic (electronic) media, machine readable document, or any other medium" if it carries the payee's name, address and TIN, which IRC 3406(a)(1)IRC 3406Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII condition applies and, where relevant, that the IRS notified the broker; it travels with the transfer or account-registration instructions. "Once the broker transmits the transfer instructions containing the required information, the broker has no further responsibility," and "Upon receiving the notice from a broker, the payor must impose withholding on the account" (IRM 20.1.10.13(3)IRM 20.1.10.13(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov-(4)). "Broker" includes a dealer, a barter exchange and "any other person who regularly acts as a middleman for property or services (for pay)" (IRM 20.1.10.13(5))IRM 20.1.10.13(5)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. $500 per willful failure, PRN 632 (IRM 20.1.10.13.1, 20.1.10.13.2)IRM 20.1.10.13.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 20.1.10.13.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The manual is silent on the payor's own IRC 3406IRC 3406Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII liability when the notice never arrives. The notice template carries the required elements and a payor acknowledgment.

For IRC 6705IRC 6705Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII and IRC 6674IRC 6674Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII the manual uses the same sentence: "Penalty relief is not granted for reasonable cause. If a taxpayer wants to contest the penalty assessment, the taxpayer must fully pay the entire penalty and then file a claim for refund" (IRM 20.1.10.13.3 and 20.1.10.9.3)IRM 20.1.10.13.3Internal Revenue Manual, revised Oct. 12, 2022, irs.govIRM 20.1.10.9.3Internal Revenue Manual, revised Oct. 12, 2022, irs.gov. No statement, no examiner to persuade; the route is Form 843 after payment.

IRC 6674 and 6682: the willful W-2 and the false W-9

IRC 6674IRC 6674Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII reaches anyone required to furnish a W-2 or tip statement "who willfully furnishes a false or fraudulent statement or willfully fails to furnish a statement": $50 per failure, PRN 575, on Form 8278 (IRM 20.1.10.9, 20.1.10.9.2)IRM 20.1.10.9Internal Revenue Manual, revised Oct. 12, 2022, irs.govIRM 20.1.10.9.2Internal Revenue Manual, revised Oct. 12, 2022, irs.gov. "When firm indications of willful failure ... are discovered, the investigating office will suspend the inquiry and refer the matter to the Criminal Investigation function." The 1099 payee-statement penalty is IRC 6722IRC 6722Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII, in another chapter.

IRC 6682IRC 6682Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII is the weight behind the Form W-9 jurat: a penalty on "any individual who makes a statement under IRC 3402IRC 3402Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII ... or IRC 3406IRC 3406Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII, Backup Withholding, that results in a decrease in the amounts deducted and withheld ... if it had no reasonable basis at the time the statement was made" (IRM 20.1.10.10(1))IRM 20.1.10.10(1)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Oct. 12, 2022, irs.gov. $500 per false statement, PRN 616, Form 8278 (IRM 20.1.10.10.1, 20.1.10.10.2)IRM 20.1.10.10.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 20.1.10.10.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Two exits: "reasonable basis for the statement at the time," and a waiver "if the individual's taxes for that year are equal to or less than the sum of the: Allowable credits ... and Estimated tax payments" (IRM 20.1.10.10.2(2), 20.1.10.10.3)IRM 20.1.10.10.2(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 20.1.10.10.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A payer's solicitation letters may cite it; the manual describes no payer role.

IRC 6652(a) and 6652(l): sub-$10 statements and Form 8806

A dividend or patronage dividend under $10 needs a statement for one reason: "Treas. Reg 1.6042-2 limits the filing requirement for payments less than $10 to shareholders subject to backup withholding requirements under IRC 3406IRC 3406Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII," with the same rule for cooperatives (IRM 20.1.10.6.1(2)IRM 20.1.10.6.1(2)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov-(3), Aug. 12, 2026). $1 per statement, $1,000 per calendar year, PRN 590, Form 8278, reasonable cause available (IRM 20.1.10.6.1.1IRM 20.1.10.6.1.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov to 6.1.3). It does not apply to payments to foreign corporations or nonresident aliens (IRM 20.1.10.6.1(7))IRM 20.1.10.6.1(7)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov; a paragraph of the assertion criteria is redacted.

Form 8806 is due "on or before the 45th day following the acquisition of control or substantial change in capital structure ... or, if earlier, on or before January 5th of the year following"; shareholders receiving $1,000 or less are exempt; and "Failure to file also includes the failure to satisfy the requirement to file on magnetic media" (IRM 20.1.10.6.5(3)IRM 20.1.10.6.5(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov-(12), Aug. 12, 2026). The penalty is not per return: the Form 8806 "and all Forms 1099-CAP required to be filed will be considered as one return for penalty computation," at $500 per day up to $100,000, PRN 649, "systemically assessable," reasonable cause available (IRM 20.1.10.6.5.1; 20.1.10.6.5.2)IRM 20.1.10.6.5.1Internal Revenue Manual, revised Oct. 12, 2022, irs.govIRM 20.1.10.6.5.2Internal Revenue Manual, revised Nov. 18, 2019, irs.gov.

IRC 6657: the dishonored EFTPS deposit

Since July 2, 2010 the dishonored-check penalty covers "any 'instrument in payment, by any commercially acceptable means,'" including "EFTPS payments and deposits" (IRM 20.1.10.7(2))IRM 20.1.10.7(2)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Nov. 18, 2019, irs.gov. A returned Form 945 or 1042 deposit draws 2% of the payment if $1,250 or more, $25 if $25 to $1,249.99, and the payment amount if $5 to $24.99 (IRM 20.1.10.7.1(1))IRM 20.1.10.7.1(1)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov; three notes and a reminder there are redacted. Relief needs paper: "Oral testimony to that effect will not be accepted. The first time abate (FTA) administrative waiver does not apply." "A bank letter is required if the reason is bank error" (IRM 20.1.10.7.3)IRM 20.1.10.7.3Internal Revenue Manual, revised Aug. 20, 2024, irs.gov. Reason codes: bank error PRC 017; EFTPS or Treasury Financial Agent error PRC 032; a stop payment mis-coded as dishonored PRC 045 or 017; erroneous IRS advice PRC 044 (IRM 20.1.10.7.4)IRM 20.1.10.7.4Internal Revenue Manual, revised Oct. 12, 2022, irs.gov. Letter 608-C asks for information; Letter 854-C denies. The IRC 6657 calculator applies the tiers and names the route.

The Form 8278 path: no 30-day letter, CP 215 first

Assessable penalties are "paid upon notice and demand. For assessable penalties, there is no 30-day letter, no agreement form, and no notice requirements prior to assessment" (IRM 20.1.9.1.5(2))IRM 20.1.9.1.5(2)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Jan. 29, 2021, irs.gov. A payer used to the 972CG proposal stage should expect none here; the first document may be the CP 215 on MFT 13, which opens "We charged you a penalty under section", shows a balance table, and on page two tells the taxpayer "what to do if his or her refund claim has been pending for more than six months" (IRM 20.1.9.1.5(15); Exhibit 20.1.9-7)IRM 20.1.9.1.5(15)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM Exhibit 20.1.9-7Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. "The taxpayer's signature is not required" (IRM 20.1.9.2.2(5))IRM 20.1.9.2.2(5)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.

Supervisory approval is the check a payer can test: "both the originator and supervisor sign and date each page of the form on which penalties are proposed," or the file goes back on Form 3210 (IRM 20.1.10.2(9))IRM 20.1.10.2(9)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Aug. 12, 2026, irs.gov. The exception for penalties "automatically calculated through electronic means" ends once "an IRS employee considers the response prior to assessment"; then "written supervisory approval under IRC 6751(b)(1)IRC 6751Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII, is required" (IRM 20.1.10.2(7))IRM 20.1.10.2(7)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. After assessment, "Appeals currently provides a prepayment, post assessment appeal process" under IRM 8.11.5IRM 8.11.5Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, opened by the "taxpayer's written request for appeal of penalties" (IRM 20.1.9.1.5(5), 20.1.9.2.3)IRM 20.1.9.1.5(5)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 20.1.9.2.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Only the assessing unit can abate; "Collection personnel do not have delegated authority" (IRM 20.1.9.2.4)IRM 20.1.9.2.4Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.

Two statutes

For the miscellaneous penalties, "To the extent such an item pertains to an information return, the assessment is not subject to the period of limitation in IRC 6501IRC 6501Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII; however, discretion should be used when determining the periods on which information return penalties are assessed" (IRM 20.1.10.2.2(1))IRM 20.1.10.2.2(1)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Aug. 12, 2026, irs.gov. For international information returns, penalties "generally must be assessed within three years after the return was filed," and under IRC 6501(c)(8)IRC 6501Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII an incomplete return holds the period open until three years after the missing information arrives (IRM 20.1.9.1.5(3))IRM 20.1.9.1.5(3)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Jan. 29, 2021, irs.gov. A payer assuming a three-year horizon on a 1099-adjacent penalty has the manual against it.

The international reasonable-cause standard

"It is not reasonable or prudent for taxpayers to have no knowledge of, or to solely rely on others for, the tax treatment of international transactions" (IRM 20.1.9.1.5(4))IRM 20.1.9.1.5(4)Internal Revenue Manual, revised Jan. 29, 2021, irs.gov. Relief "should not be granted" merely because "The taxpayer relied on another person to file returns. It is the taxpayer's responsibility to ensure that all returns are filed timely and accurately."

Where reasonable cause is available, requests "should contain a declaration that it is made under the penalties of perjury" (IRM 20.1.9.1.5(4))IRM 20.1.9.1.5(4)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. "The fact that reasonable cause relief was granted to the related income tax return does not automatically provide relief for the failure to timely file the information returns." Examiners are "encouraged to ensure the taxpayer is in full compliance ... prior to considering reasonable cause on any one year," and "A taxpayer's testimony that records were not available year after year has no merit" (IRM 20.1.9.2(15))IRM 20.1.9.2(15)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Put the perjury declaration in every statement and file every open year before asking.

Where the 1042-S penalties are not

IRM 20.1.9IRM 20.1.9Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov has no procedure for a late or incorrect Form 1042-S. Its only Form 1042 content says withholding under IRC 1441IRC 1441Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII, 1442 and 1446 is "subject to failure to deposit penalties as discussed in IRM 20.1.4IRM 20.1.4Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov," and its exhibit lists Forms 1042 and 1042-S with "Refer to IRM 4.10.21IRM 4.10.21Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov" (IRM 20.1.9.25(3); Exhibit 20.1.9-2)IRM 20.1.9.25(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM Exhibit 20.1.9-2Internal Revenue Manual, revised Jan. 29, 2021, irs.gov. See the foreign-vendor exam guide and the Form 1042 deposit calculator.

The one defense that is not reasonable cause: time

None of the penalties above can be assessed after the statute closes, and for information-return penalties the clock is per return: three years from the due date if the return was filed on time, three years from the filing date if it was late, and no limit at all if it was never filed (IRM 4.23.9.13.6IRM 4.23.9.13.6Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, Oct. 6, 2022; Exhibit 4.23.9-1, citing IRC 6501(c)(3)IRC 6501Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII). An employment-tax statute extension on Form SS-10 "does not extend the statute of limitations on these penalties." Before any argument about intent or cause, check the dates on the statute page.

Questions people ask

We were assessed PRN 632 and had a good reason. Can we write a reasonable-cause statement?

Not under this manual. For IRC 6705IRC 6705Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII the route is to "fully pay the entire penalty and then file a claim for refund" (IRM 20.1.10.13.3)IRM 20.1.10.13.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A Form 843 claim on a paid penalty carries Appeals and suit rights; an unpaid abatement request does not.

Our EFTPS deposit bounced because the bank coded it wrong. What do we send?

A written request with the bank's letter: "A bank letter is required if the reason is bank error" (IRM 20.1.10.7.3)IRM 20.1.10.7.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, coded PRC 017. Expect Letter 608-C if more is wanted and Letter 854-C if denied.

Can we ask for the supervisor's approval record?

The manual requires both signatures on every page of the Form 8278 (IRM 20.1.10.2(9))IRM 20.1.10.2(9)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Asking for it in the Appeals request is reasonable; whether a missing signature voids the assessment is a legal question the manual does not answer.