Three kinds of employment tax audit
The IRS employment tax program has revenue agents, revenue officer examiners, Tax Compliance Officers and Tax Examiners (IRM 4.23.19.2)IRM 4.23.19.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A group manager uses this table to decide who gets each case (IRM 4.23.19.3)IRM 4.23.19.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
| Correspondence audit (Tax Examiner) | Remote audit (Tax Compliance Officer) | Field audit (revenue agent, revenue officer examiner, tax specialist) |
|---|---|---|
| Initial interview limited and not required | Initial interview required, with follow-up verbal contact | Initial interview required, with extensive verbal contact expected |
| Records can be verified to source documents that are easily sent by mail | Source documents may need follow-up and tax law interpretation | A tour of the business is required to set the initial scope |
| Limited review of journals, ledgers or other books and records | Multiple non-filed returns may be involved, generally for only one entity | Complex areas of tax law may need analysis |
| Limited analysis of information | Limited third party contacts may be needed to corroborate testimony | Transactions among multiple related entities may be identified and developed |
| Verification issues only | Simple to complex issues that can be submitted by mail for review | Expanded third party contacts may be required |
| Badges of fraud are not apparent | Fraud may be identified and developed, or referred to the field | Fraud may be identified from referrals and other outside sources |
| Limited scope, using Lead Sheet 130 | Financial records may need review to develop issues | Complex and multiple issues |
| Referred to another examiner if scope and depth change | Suited to remote audit procedures | Complex books and records are likely; on-site inspection may be required |
A Tax Examiner case can involve non-filed periods or a full-year Combined Annual Wage Reporting (CAWR) assessment with no other issues (IRM 4.23.19.3.1)IRM 4.23.19.3.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The campus non-filer program is separate from all three and has its own manual section; see IRS Letters 4107 and 4108. The grading exhibit in IRM 4.23.19IRM 4.23.19Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov matches cases to IRS staff grades and is left out here.
What a TCO can work
The manual says TCO cases must be conducive to the remote audit process and must: “Involve limited scope of not more than one or two issues identified during classification.” (IRM 4.23.21.4)IRM 4.23.21.4Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The assignment criteria add that no related entities were identified, and this: “Worker classification and potential section 530 issues are not identified during initial classification” (IRM 4.23.19.3.2)IRM 4.23.19.3.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The same subsection lists work that can go to a TCO:
- Form 1120-S officer compensation and related fringe benefits, where distributions are evident on the face of the return.
- CAWR cases.
- “Backup Withholding not involving a worker classification determination”.
- Fringe benefit issues such as bonus payments not properly treated.
- Claims and referrals that otherwise meet the TCO criteria.
So a backup withholding issue that involves no worker classification determination can be assigned to a TCO and examined by telephone and mail. A Form 945 compliance check is a different contact; see the Form 945 compliance check.
How the audit runs
- The appointment letter. “Letter 3850-T, Employment Tax TCO Appointment, will be issued to schedule a date and time for a telephone interview; this letter was specifically developed for use in a remote audit.” It comes with Publication 1, Publication 5146 and Notice 609 (IRM 4.23.21.5.1)IRM 4.23.21.5.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
- The information document request (IDR). A Form 4564 is attached to the letter. It is tailored to you: specific to the issues, stating the tax periods, a due date and a method for sending the documents, and asking for copies of income tax returns the IRS cannot see electronically. “In a remote audit, the requested information will be due to the ET TCO prior to the initial telephone interview.” (IRM 4.23.21.5.1)IRM 4.23.21.5.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
- The telephone interview. “Interviews are required in ET TCO examinations.” It covers whether there are other employment tax issues or related entities, why the filing or reporting went wrong, and whether it was intentional (IRM 4.23.21.5.2)IRM 4.23.21.5.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
- Before the report. “The ET TCO must notify the taxpayer of the examination of all periods and returns in which adjustments are being proposed prior to the issuance of the 30-day letter and report.” (IRM 4.23.21.6.2)IRM 4.23.21.6.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
- If you ask for an appeal. “ET TCOs must offer a managerial conference or Fast Track Settlement (FTS) to all taxpayers when a request for an appeal is received.” (IRM 4.23.21.6.2)IRM 4.23.21.6.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
The letters
| Letter | Purpose | Timing in the manual |
|---|---|---|
| Letter 3850-T, Employment Tax TCO Appointment | Schedules the telephone interview in a remote audit; Form 4564 attached | Documents due before the interview |
| Letter 3850, Employment Tax Appointment Letter | Schedules a face-to-face appointment when you are in the TCO’s area; Form 4564 attached | Documents due at the appointment |
| Letter 3850-F, Employment Tax Second Contact | Follow-up when you did not respond or did not keep the appointment | Appointment within sixteen calendar days, IDR response within eleven calendar days |
| Letter 923-P | Extends the time to file a protest when you said you intend to file one but have not | Issued within seven calendar days after the original 30-day letter expires |
| Letter 3523 | Notice of Employment Tax Determination Under IRC Section 7436, in unagreed cases that require it | None stated |
Sources: IRM 4.23.21.5.1IRM 4.23.21.5.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, 4.23.21.6.3 and 4.23.21.7. The manual does not say which day the sixteen and eleven day counts start from, so go by the dates printed on Letter 3850-F.
If you do not respond
If you do not answer the letter or miss the appointment, the TCO must try again, by telephone or by Letter 3850-F. On the telephone attempt: “The ET TCO will not leave a message for the taxpayer to return the call.” Then: “If the ET TCO does not have a valid telephone number or the taxpayer does not answer, the ET TCO will issue the Letter 3850-F to schedule the follow-up appointment within sixteen calendar days, and the IDR response within eleven calendar days.” (IRM 4.23.21.6.3)IRM 4.23.21.6.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
Not answering does not end the audit. The manual: “If the ET TCO can determine a substantially correct wage adjustment from the information available, a 30-day letter and report will be issued, even if the taxpayer fails to keep the appointment scheduled in Letter 3850-F or makes no attempt to reschedule.” (IRM 4.23.21.6.3)IRM 4.23.21.6.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The report is then built from what the IRS already has.
If the TCO cannot work out a substantially correct adjustment, the options the manual lists are transfer to a field group, a summons, or closing the case by survey (IRM 4.23.21.6.3)IRM 4.23.21.6.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
Manager approval and transfer to the field
A TCO must get a manager’s approval when (IRM 4.23.21.5.4)IRM 4.23.21.5.4Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov:
- the scope is being changed from the classified issues;
- there are indications that a worker reclassification issue needs to be developed;
- the taxpayer cannot be located and a decision is needed on whether to continue;
- the TCO cannot determine a substantially correct wage adjustment from the information available;
- transfer to a field group may be warranted;
- penalties that need managerial approval, such as negligence, are being proposed.
On transfers the manual says: “If issues outside the scope for TCOs are found during development, the case should be transferred to the appropriate field examiner to complete the examination.” (IRM 4.23.19.3.2)IRM 4.23.19.3.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Worker classification, the IRC 3509IRC 3509Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII rates, section 530 relief, the Classification Settlement Program and the examination report are covered in employment tax examinations as the IRS runs them and employee or contractor.
What every case file must show
Whatever the issue, the examiner’s workpapers must document whether four steps were taken: the appropriate people were interviewed, all required employment tax and information returns were accurately and timely filed, Forms W-2 were reconciled to payroll, and this: “All required Form(s) 1099 were correctly filed, for example no worker reclassification issue exists or backup withholding is not warranted.” Skipping a step has to be explained: “The examiner will document the reason for not addressing any of the above actions.” (IRM 4.23.4.2)IRM 4.23.4.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
IRM 4.23.4.3IRM 4.23.4.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov lists the lead sheets that are mandatory in all employment tax cases, except where noted:
| Number | Lead sheet |
|---|---|
| 000 | Form 4318 ET, Employment Tax Examination Workpapers, Index |
| 100 | Activity Record, Form 9984 |
| 105 | Administrative Lead Sheet |
| 115 | GM Concurrence Meeting Check Sheet |
| 120 | Initial Taxpayer Contact Check Sheet |
| 125-1 | Initial Appointment Agenda |
| 125-2 | Initial Interview Questions |
| 130-1 | Multi-Year and Related Returns Lead Sheet |
| 130-2 | 1099 Filing Requirement Checks |
| 135 | Records Check List |
| 140 | Mandatory Issues Check Sheet |
| 150 | Risk Analysis Workpaper |
| 200 | Payroll Reconciliation & Evaluation |
| 205-1 | Fraud Awareness Lead Sheet |
| 300 | Penalty Approval Form |
| 940 | Closing Documents, Closing Conference Agenda |
Sheets 115, 140 and 150 are not required for TCOs or limited scope exams. Sheet 135 is not required on no-response cases or limited scope exams, and sheet 940 is not required on no-response cases. The manual names the Records Check List but does not reproduce it, so nothing on this page is the IRS’s official document checklist. Your IDR is the list that counts. See also 1099 checks in every IRS audit.
When the audit ends with tax due
When tax is proposed, the examiner gives you a calculation of the tax, projected interest and penalties. Then comes the request for payment: “Examiners must request full payment in all agreed employment tax cases.” If you cannot pay in full within 120 days of the first notice, an installment agreement is considered with Collection (IRM 4.23.11.2)IRM 4.23.11.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
The closing file is marked if you are entitled to an interest-free period under IRC 6205IRC 6205Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII (IRM 4.23.21.7)IRM 4.23.21.7Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. But: “The taxpayer will owe interest if full payment is not made by the assessment date, even if the interest-free provisions otherwise apply.” In unpaid cases the examiner records any bank or financial information obtained during the examination on Form 9440 for Collection (IRM 4.23.11.2.1)IRM 4.23.11.2.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
Getting ready
- Read the IDR first. Note the tax periods, the due date and the delivery method.
- Send the documents by that date, before the interview, and keep copies of everything you send.
- Be available at the scheduled time. If you cannot be, call the number on the letter. On a follow-up call the TCO will not leave a message.
- Be ready to explain why a return was not filed or an amount was not reported.
- Keep proof of the Forms W-2 and 1099 you filed, and a reconciliation of Forms W-2 to payroll. The examiner must document whether both checks were made.
- If you disagree with the report, answer within the 30 days and ask for the managerial conference or Fast Track Settlement.
Questions people ask
What is Letter 3850-T?
It is the appointment letter a Tax Compliance Officer sends to schedule the telephone interview in a remote employment tax audit. A Form 4564 information document request is attached, and the documents are due before the interview (IRM 4.23.21.5.1)IRM 4.23.21.5.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
What is Letter 3850-F?
The second contact letter, used when you did not respond. It schedules a follow-up appointment within sixteen calendar days and an IDR response within eleven calendar days (IRM 4.23.21.6.3)IRM 4.23.21.6.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
Can a desk audit turn into a field audit?
Yes. If issues outside the TCO’s scope turn up, the case should be transferred to a field examiner (IRM 4.23.19.3.2)IRM 4.23.19.3.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
Can backup withholding be examined in a desk audit?
Yes, when no worker classification determination is involved. IRM 4.23.19.3.2IRM 4.23.19.3.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov lists it among the issues that can be assigned to a TCO.
Will the examiner look at our Forms 1099 even if the audit is about something else?
Expect it. The workpapers must document whether all required Forms 1099 were correctly filed, or the reason that step was not addressed (IRM 4.23.4.2)IRM 4.23.4.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.