What the campus non-filer program is
The Employment Tax Non-Filer (ETNF) program is worked at the IRS Cincinnati campus. Its tax examiners prepare Substitute for Return (SFR) employment tax returns for employers that did not file. The manual lists these employment tax forms (IRM 4.23.26.1.1)IRM 4.23.26.1.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov:
- Form 941, Employer’s QUARTERLY Federal Tax Return
- Form 943, Employer’s Annual Tax Return for Agricultural Employees
- Form 944, Employer’s ANNUAL Federal Tax Return
- Form 945, Annual Return of Withheld Federal Income Tax
- Form 940, Employer’s Annual Federal Unemployment Tax Return
- Form 1040 and Schedule H, Household Employment Taxes
“Employment tax returns do not follow statutory notice of deficiency procedures.” (IRM 4.23.26.1.1)IRM 4.23.26.1.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
The campus works these cases by letter, phone and fax. The remote employment tax audit is a different process: see the employment tax desk audit.
How a case starts
The manual describes the starting point this way: “The SFR program was developed to contact taxpayers who have not filed tax returns voluntarily and for whom income information is available to substantiate a significant tax liability.” (IRM 4.23.26.6)IRM 4.23.26.6Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. In this program the income information is wage data. The examiner takes Social Security and Medicare wages and tips, and federal income tax withholding, from the IRS record of information returns on file for the employer (IRM 4.23.26.5)IRM 4.23.26.5Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, and the case file holds that record for each tax year with a sort of the Forms W-2 (IRM 4.23.26.12)IRM 4.23.26.12Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
Form 945. The manual lists Form 945 among the forms, applies the tiered deposit penalty to it, and names it in the step for returns that do not match Form W-2 wages (IRM 4.23.26.1.1, 4.23.26.9.1, 4.23.26.14)IRM 4.23.26.1.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 4.23.26.9.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 4.23.26.14Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. It does not describe a method for building a Form 945 from Forms 1099. For that subject, see unfiled Form 945: what the IRS does and the Form 945 backup withholding compliance check.
The letters and the days
The first letter: “In most instances, the Batch Leveraging Processing (BLP) Team will issue Letter 4107, Initial Contact Letter-No Employment Tax Returns Filed, with a 17-day suspense period.” (IRM 4.23.26.3)IRM 4.23.26.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A suspense period is the time the campus holds the case before its next step. Your own response date is the one printed on the letter.
| Letter | What it says | Days stated in the manual | What happens next |
|---|---|---|---|
| Letter 4107, Initial Contact Letter, No Employment Tax Returns Filed | The IRS has no employment tax return on file and is starting an examination. | Issued with a 17-day suspense period (IRM 4.23.26.3)IRM 4.23.26.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. | With no reply, Letter 4108 is issued (IRM 4.23.26.5)IRM 4.23.26.5Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. |
| Letter 4108, 30 Day Letter to Taxpayer, No Employment Tax Returns Have been Filed | Sends the proposed examination report (Form 2504-S, Form 4666, Form 4667 and/or Form 4668) with Form 886-A, Explanation of Items (IRM 4.23.26.5)IRM 4.23.26.5Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. | It is the 30-day letter. The campus holds the case for a 45 day suspense period after this second contact (IRM 4.23.26.7)IRM 4.23.26.7Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. | With no reply, the case is closed by default after Day 46 (IRM 4.23.26.8)IRM 4.23.26.8Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. |
| Letter 4109, and Letter 4110, No Change Letter When Taxpayer Provides Missing Employment Tax Returns | Closing letters. See the response chart below. | None stated. | Case closed (IRM 4.23.26.4)IRM 4.23.26.4Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. |
On silence the manual says: “If taxpayers do not respond to the exam, close case default after Day 46.” (IRM 4.23.26.8)IRM 4.23.26.8Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. On replies it says: “All responses from a taxpayer must be examined; however, requesting additional information in response to Letter 4108 is limited to two attempts.” In every contact the examiner is to tell you the deadline for requesting an IRS Appeals hearing (IRM 4.23.26.4)IRM 4.23.26.4Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. A representative gets a copy of the letters only if a power of attorney is on file for all periods under examination (IRM 4.23.26.3, 4.23.26.5)IRM 4.23.26.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 4.23.26.5Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
What you can send back, and how each reply is handled
Replies to Letter 4107 and Letter 4108 are handled the same way as long as no assessment is on the account. Several steps below use a short letter the manual calls a quick note.
| Your reply | What the campus does (IRM 4.23.26.4)IRM 4.23.26.4Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov |
|---|---|
| You say the return was filed but send no copy | Researches the account. If it cannot find the return, sends a quick note. |
| You say the returns were filed under another EIN | If research confirms it, closes the case “No Change” and issues Letter 4109. If not, sends a quick note with copies of the information return record. |
| You send signed returns that match the information on file | Closes the case “Agreed” and issues Letter 4110. |
| You send signed returns that support only part of the information on file | Accepts the returns and assesses the reported wages. Sends a quick note and a revised report for the unreported wages. If you were answering Letter 4107, Letter 4108 is also sent. |
| You sign and return Form 2504 in reply to Letter 4108 | Closes the case “Agreed.” |
| You say you had no employees in the periods | Refers the case to Field Employment Tax. |
Signing the agreement form is not the same as filing. The manual: “If the taxpayer executes a waiver the signature on the Form 2504 does not constitute a return under IRC 6020(a)IRC 6020Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII and therefore does not commence the running of the assessment statute of limitations.” (IRM 4.23.12.4.3)IRM 4.23.12.4.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The campus closes the case as agreed when a signed Form 2504 comes back, but the assessment period starts only when the IRS receives a valid signed return.
How the IRS builds the return, and the IRC 6020(b) certification
For the report sent with Letter 4108, the examiner enters the wages, tips and federal income tax withholding from the information return record, then your timely deposits (IRM 4.23.26.5)IRM 4.23.26.5Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. When the case closes without your return, the examiner completes Form 13496-A, IRC Section 6020(b) Certification for Employment Tax Returns, for each tax period. It is an internal form and is not sent to you (IRM 4.23.26.6)IRM 4.23.26.6Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
The general delinquent return rules count periods the same way: “Each quarterly Form 941 (and/or yearly Form 940, Form 943, Form 944, Form 945) constitutes a separate tax period.” They also say: “IRC 6020(b)IRC 6020Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII procedures will never apply when a valid return is received from the taxpayer.” (IRM 4.23.12.4.3)IRM 4.23.12.4.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Each period stands alone, so filing some periods takes those periods out (IRM 4.23.12.4.2)IRM 4.23.12.4.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
In the general delinquent return rules, which are written for employment tax examiners outside the campus, examiners are told: “If no indications of fraud are present, advise the taxpayer that he/she is required to file all delinquent returns without regard to the number of years or taxable periods involved.” and “Inform the taxpayer that failure to tender the delinquent return(s) by the specified date will be considered a refusal to file.” (IRM 4.23.12.2)IRM 4.23.12.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
Penalties
- Failure to file. “The FTF penalty rate to be assessed at closure is 22.5 percent.” It is computed as 22.5 percent of the tax assessed in the examination minus total timely payments (IRM 4.23.26.9.2)IRM 4.23.26.9.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. That is the rate this manual section gives for closing these cases.
- Failure to deposit. The rate at closing is 10 percent on the same base, and an additional 5 percent tier is assessed if the assessed tax is paid late. The tiered penalty applies only to Forms 940, 941, 943, 944 and 945 (IRM 4.23.26.9.1)IRM 4.23.26.9.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The manual’s public version withholds part of this section, including the point by which payment avoids the additional tier. See Form 941 deposits and the failure to deposit penalty.
- Failure to pay and interest. Both are generated after the examination closes (IRM 4.23.26.9)IRM 4.23.26.9Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, and the manual warns: “IRC 6020(b)IRC 6020Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII tax return does not stop the FTP penalty.” (IRM 4.23.26.6)IRM 4.23.26.6Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
Penalty relief can be requested during or after the examination, and the examiner must document whether reasonable cause was established (IRM 4.23.26.9.3)IRM 4.23.26.9.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Ask, because the general rule is: “The failure to file and failure to pay penalties are automatic penalties and will be asserted unless case processing is notified otherwise.” (IRM 4.23.12.6)IRM 4.23.12.6Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. See first-time abate and the relief order.
Signatures and what makes a return valid
“An unsigned return is not a valid return. A faxed signature is acceptable.” (IRM 4.23.26.11)IRM 4.23.26.11Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The signer must be authorized for the type of business:
| Business entity | Who signs (IRM 4.23.26.11)IRM 4.23.26.11Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov |
|---|---|
| Sole proprietorship | The business owner |
| Corporation, including an LLC treated as a corporation | The president, vice president, or other principal officer duly authorized to sign |
| Partnership, including an LLC treated as a partnership | A responsible and duly authorized partner, member, or officer having knowledge of its affairs |
| Single-member LLC treated as a disregarded entity | The owner of the LLC or a principal officer duly authorized to sign |
| Trust or estate | The fiduciary |
A duly authorized agent may sign if a valid power of attorney has been filed. A signature alone does not start the assessment period: the manual says more information is required than just a taxpayer signature (IRM 4.23.12.4.2)IRM 4.23.12.4.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
After assessment, and the statute of limitations
Reconsideration. A return sent in after the assessment goes to the Cincinnati Exam Reconsideration Team (IRM 4.23.26.16)IRM 4.23.26.16Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. For an unsigned return the campus makes one phone attempt if it has a number. If it has none, it sends Letter 21-C asking for the signature and holds the case for 45 days (IRM 4.23.26.16.3.1)IRM 4.23.26.16.3.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Go by the date on the letter. A signed return is compared with the Forms W-2 on file. If it reports less, it is not accepted, and the IRS explains why in Letter 105-C or Letter 916-C (IRM 4.23.26.16.3.2, 4.23.26.16.3.3)IRM 4.23.26.16.3.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 4.23.26.16.3.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
The statute. “IRC 6020(b)IRC 6020Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII tax return does not start the statute of limitations on an assessment.” (IRM 4.23.26.6)IRM 4.23.26.6Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. When a signed return is received, the campus sets the assessment statute date from it (IRM 4.23.26.8)IRM 4.23.26.8Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov, and the general rule is 3 years from the date the IRS received the return (IRM 4.23.12.4.2)IRM 4.23.12.4.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
What to do when Letter 4107 arrives
- List the forms and periods in the letter and check your records for each, including returns filed under a different EIN.
- If a return was filed, send a copy. If you send only a statement, the campus researches the account and writes again if it cannot find the return.
- If it was not filed, prepare it, have the authorized person sign it, and send it as the letter directs. Check the wages and withholding against the Forms W-2 you filed.
- Reply by the date on the letter, and call the number on the letter with questions.
- Pay what the returns show, and make current deposits on time.
- If you had a reason for filing late, put it in writing and ask for penalty relief.
- Keep dated copies of everything you send.
Questions people ask
What is IRS Letter 4107?
The Initial Contact Letter, No Employment Tax Returns Filed. It is the first letter in the campus Employment Tax Non-Filer program and is issued with a 17-day suspense period (IRM 4.23.26.3)IRM 4.23.26.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
What is IRS Letter 4108?
The 30-day letter in the same program. It carries the proposed examination report, with the tax computed from the wage data on file. With no response, the case is closed by default after Day 46 (IRM 4.23.26.5, 4.23.26.8)IRM 4.23.26.5Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 4.23.26.8Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
Should I sign Form 2504 or file the return?
They do different things. A signed Form 2504 closes the campus case as agreed, but it is not a return and does not start the assessment period. A valid signed return does (IRM 4.23.26.4, 4.23.12.4.3)IRM 4.23.26.4Internal Revenue Manual, irs.govIRM 4.23.12.4.3Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
We had no employees. What happens if we say so?
The campus does not decide that question. The case is referred to Field Employment Tax (IRM 4.23.26.4)IRM 4.23.26.4Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
Can we still file after the IRS has assessed the tax?
Yes. A signed return goes to the reconsideration team (IRM 4.23.26.16)IRM 4.23.26.16Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. Refunds are time limited: where no return was filed, a claim may be allowed if filed within 2 years from the date of payment (IRM 4.23.26.16.4)IRM 4.23.26.16.4Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.